Coinsurance Penalty

Updated: 18 April 2026

What Does Coinsurance Penalty Mean?

A coinsurance penalty is the amount that the insured must pay for a loss that the insurer will not cover due to insufficient coinsurance. This typically occurs when the value of the insurance purchased is less than the value of the property being covered.

Knowing how much homeowners insurance you actually need based on the full replacement cost of the property is the main way to avoid this penalty.

Insuranceopedia Explains Coinsurance Penalty

The formula to calculate the claim in property insurance is: (actual amount of insurance ÷ required amount of insurance) × amount of loss.

If the amount of insurance purchased is less than the required amount, the insured is responsible for covering part of the loss, resulting in a coinsurance penalty.

In Mr. X’s case:

  • He insured the property for $60,000, but the property’s value is $90,000.
  • The required amount of insurance based on the value is $90,000.
  • The loss from the peril amounts to $30,000.

Using the formula: ($60,000 ÷ $90,000) × $30,000 = $20,000.

The insurer will pay only $20,000. Mr. X will need to pay the remaining $10,000 out of pocket, which serves as the coinsurance penalty.

With that number in hand, you can compare the best homeowners insurance companies at the right coverage level and avoid buying too little.