Best Condo Insurance In New Jersey

Nationwide is the best condo insurance provider in New Jersey.

min read
Written by
Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Condo insurance doesn’t just protect you against financial loss in case of damage or loss to your condominium and its contents. It also brings peace of mind.

In The Garden State, severe weather events like tornadoes and thunderstorms are commonplace. Therefore, the possibility of weather damage to your condominium is not far-fetched. Say it did happen. Would you have enough coverage? If not, it means you’d have to pay for repairs yourself, which can be a burden financially, not to mention emotionally.

Don’t let this be your story. Take steps today to safeguard your unit and personal property against unforeseen events. To ensure you have enough financial protection, ensure the condo insurance policy you purchase covers a range of risks, including theft and catastrophic weather events. If you’re unsure where to start, this guide will help you find the best condo insurance in New Jersey.

Best Condo Insurance Companies In New Jersey, 2024

Best Condo Insurance, New Jersey, 2024

Compare The Best Condo Insurance Companies In New Jersey

Overall Rating Best For A.M Best Rating J.D Power Rating Get A Quote




Instant Quote




Instant Quote

High-Value Condos



Instant Quote




Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Our Methodology

To determine which condo insurance companies are the best in New Jersey, I analyzed customer satisfaction and financial strength ratings from third-party agencies, J.D. Power and AM Best, respectively. I also relied on consumer reviews from various sources and my working experience selling condo insurance as a licensed property and casualty agent in New Jersey.


Quotes Analyzed


Brands Reviewed


Years Of Experience


Research Hours

Condo Insurance Company Reviews In New Jersey

Best Overall

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Nationwide offers comprehensive policies tailored to meet customer needs, landing it the top spot in this guide. They offer various coverage options, including coverage for personal possessions (e.g., furniture and clothing) and additional living expenses.

ALE coverage reimburses you for costs incurred if you can not live in your condominium due to damage covered by your policy. In addition to standard condo insurance coverage types, policyholders can add endorsements to their policies to get even more customized protection.

Nationwide is also known for its superior claims service, with a claims team dedicated to handling claims promptly and fairly. Their commitment to excellence extends to their customer service, delivering a seamless customer experience.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Competitive prices
  • A broad range of coverage options
  • Good customer service
  • Best reserved for high-value condos
  • Limited availability discounts
  • Potential for other expenses

Best Runner-Up

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

In second place is Amica, which offers New Jersey condo owners an extensive coverage catalog. Their Platinum Choice policy provides higher coverage limits and additional protection than a standard condo insurance policy.

Amica also has very affordable rates, offering significantly cheaper premiums than Allstate. Policyholders can bundle their condo and auto insurance policies for discount savings of up to 20%. Moreover, the company has a reputation for good customer service and high customer satisfaction.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Variety of coverage options
  • Low customer complaint rate
  • Financially strong insurer
  • Higher than-average rates
  • AM Best rating downgraded in 2017
  • Condo insurance dividend policies are not available in every state

Best For High-Value Condos

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

If you own a luxury condominium in New Jersey, Chubb’s excellent customer service and specialized coverage options make it the best provider for your property’s needs. Their Masterpiece policy features extended replacement cost in the eventuality the cost to rebuild your condo exceeds the sum insured.

With a commitment to addressing the unique needs of high-net-worth condo owners, Chubb offers various add-on coverages, such as identity fraud cover and cyber cover. Their high coverage limits also speak to their commitment to providing premium protection for high-end condos.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Offers extended coverage
  • Top-notch customer service
  • A low number of complaints
  • Designed for luxury condos
  • Costs more than industry averages
  • Not BBB accredited

Best For Discounts

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

If you’re looking for a New Jersey condo insurance company that offers a variety of discounts, I recommend Travelers Insurance. Their policies come with many different saving opportunities that allow condo owners to get comprehensive protection at affordable rates.

For example, policyholders can save up to 15% with their multi-policy discount by bundling condo, auto, and other insurance policies from the provider. Bundling policies not only helps reduce your insurance costs but also makes managing your policies simpler.

Protective device discount is another Travelers condo insurance discount that rewards condo owners for installing safety devices and smart home technology in their homes. The discount encourages policyholders to take measures that lower the risk they pose to the company.

Overall, Travelers condo insurance rates are among the lowest in the market despite offering similar coverages.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Affordable rates
  • Option to bundle many forms of insurance
  • High financial strength rating
  • Limited coverage
  • May have a banned dog list

How Much Is Condo Insurance In New Jersey?

This section contains various condo insurance cost information to help you make educated decisions when shopping for a policy. The rates shown are estimates and can vary significantly. See the next section for factors that influence condo insurance rates.

The Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By City

In this first table are the average condo insurance costs in some of the most populated cities in New Jersey.

City Average Annual Rate
Brigantine $790
Mendham $490
Margate City $790
Rockaway $495
Ventnor City $775
Millington $500
Belvidere $490

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Company

This next table shows how much condo owners in New Jersey can expect to pay annually for condo insurance from ten leading providers.

Insurance Company Average Annual Rate
Franklin Mutual $240
American Family $785
Palisades $340
USAA $675
Farmers $355
Chubb $465
New Jersey Manufacturers $380
State Farm $465

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Building Property Limits

Condo insurance is not a one-size-fits-all. How much coverage you need largely depends on the cost of rebuilding your condominium. The comparison table below showcases the average monthly premiums for different building limits.

Building Property Limit Average Annual Rate
$100,000 $1,304
$80,000 $1,103
$60,000 $902
$40,000 $751

Don’t focus so much on finding the cheapest rates that you inadvertently skimp on insurance. Instead, look for a policy that balances cost, coverage, financial strength, and quality customer service.

Factors That Impact The Cost Of Your Condo Insurance Policy

Several variables could impact your condo insurance premium in New Jersey, including:

Replacement Cost Of Your Condo

The higher the replacement cost value of your dwelling, the higher your condo insurance rates. Replacement cost coverage pays to rebuild your condominium to its original condition after a covered hazard.

Location Of Your Condo

Where you live is one of the most important factors that impact your condo insurance rates. If your condo’s location has a high crime rate, you’ll likely pay more for coverage. The same goes if the area is prone to natural disasters, like hailstorms, thunderstorms, and high winds—some of New Jersey’s most common extreme weather events.

Age And Construction Type Of Your Condo

The age of your condominium and the materials that make it up also determine how much you pay for condo insurance. Older condos have dated wiring, plumbing, or heating systems, making them riskier and consequently expensive to insure. Similarly, construction materials that reduce the risk of damage or loss can lower your insurance costs.

Claims History

Another factor that can affect your condo insurance premiums is your personal claims history. Insurers may view policyholders with a history of filing insurance claims as high risk, thereby charging them higher premiums. While those with a clean claims record may qualify for reduced premium rates for the opposite reason.

How To Find The Best Condo Insurance Company For You

A condo insurance policy that provides adequate coverage for your unique needs is a good investment. It covers your condominium, which is most likely your most valuable asset, and your belongings, protecting you and your loved ones financially.

To help make the process of finding the right provider and insurance plan less tasking, follow these steps:

  1. Assess how much coverage you need.
  2. Search condo insurers online and narrow down your options to three that best match your needs.
  3. Get quotes from the three providers.
  4. Evaluate each insurer based on their policy coverage, insurance costs, policy discounts, financial rating, and customer reviews.
  5. Buy condo insurance from your chosen provider.

How To Get An Online Condo Insurance Quote In New Jersey

The best way to find quality insurance in New Jersey is to compare multiple quotes from leading condo insurance providers. Insuranceopedia is a great website to get you started. To get accurate quotes, you’ll need to provide certain information, including:

  • Your name
  • Your physical address
  • The year the condo was built
  • The exterior wall construction
  • Square footage of your condo
  • The cost to rebuild your condo
  • Estimated value personal property value
  • Number of people living in the condo
  • Your personal claims history
  • Installed safety and security devices

How To Save Money On New Jersey Condo Insurance

There are various ways to find affordable but comprehensive condo insurance in New Jersey. The most straightforward way is to increase your deductible, as a high deductible typically means cheaper premiums. But should you file a claim, you’ll pay more out-of-pocket, so first consider your financial standing.

Weatherproofing and burglar-proofing your condo is another way to lower your insurance rates while mitigating the risk of weather damage and break-ins. It may entail installing storm shutters and home security devices.


How does condo insurance work?

Condo insurance offers condo owners financial protection against various risks to their condominiums and belongings through a broad range of coverage options and policy add-ons.

What does condo insurance cover in New Jersey?

Also known as an HO-6 policy, a condo insurance policy covers the interior structures of your condominium and the contents within from unexpected damage or loss. The former includes the walls, floors, fixtures, and cabinets, while the latter refers to your personal property.

Condo insurance also provides liability coverage and generally includes $1,000 worth of loss assessment coverage to pay for losses affecting shared areas of the condominium complex. You can increase the coverage limits with a policy endorsement.

How much condo insurance is required in New Jersey?

While New Jersey does not require condo insurance by law, your mortgage lender or condo association likely will. It fills in the gaps left by your condo association’s master insurance policy, ensuring you’re adequately covered

How much condo insurance do I need in New Jersey?

How much coverage you need will largely depend on the cost of rebuilding your condominium and the value of your personal belongings. For liability coverage, limits typically fall between $100,000 and $500,000.

How much is condo insurance in New Jersey?

As a condominium owner in New Jersey, expect to pay $121 a month or $1,457 annually for condo insurance. Remember, insurance rates can vary considerably depending on your location, how much coverage you obtain, and your claims history, among other factors.


Go back to top