Best Condo Insurance In Indiana 2024

Nationwide delivers the best condo insurance coverage in Indiana.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $450 per year on their home insurance.

Offers from America's top insurance carriers
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Welcome to your ultimate guide on Indiana’s best condo insurance. With 13 years of expertise as a licensed insurance agent, I assure you that this is the right place for key information. Getting the right condo insurance is paramount—not only for investment protection but also for your peace of mind.

Neglecting to take action can lead to severe consequences. In my 13 years in the insurance business, I’ve seen many condo owners face substantial financial losses due to insufficient coverage. Don’t let this be your story. Instead, let’s dive into Indiana’s condo insurance, examine your options, and ensure you’re well-protected.

Best Condo Insurance Companies In Indiana, 2024

Best Condo Insurance, Indiana2024

Compare The Best Condo Insurance Companies In Indiana

Best For Overall Rating A.M Best Rating J.D Power Rating Average Monthly Cost Get A Quote






Instant Quote






Instant Quote

High-Value Condos





Instant Quote






Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Our Methodology

To determine the best condo insurance providers in Indiana, I used objective data from AM Best (financial strength) and J.D. Power (customer satisfaction). I also considered feedback from consumer sites and drew on my experience as a former licensed property and casualty agent who sold condo insurance in Indiana.


Quotes Analyzed


Brands Reviewed


Years Of Experience


Research Hours

Best Condo Insurance Companies In Indiana

Best Overall

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Nationwide is a superior choice for condo insurance in Indiana, offering comprehensive coverage tailored to the specific needs of condo owners. This ensures you are not only covered but covered effectively.

Nationwide’s protection for condo owners is extensive, covering your furniture, clothing, and personal items from covered losses and reimbursing additional living expenses if you can’t live in your home due to a covered loss.

The superior claims service is what sets Nationwide apart. When you need help, you want an insurer who is prompt and fair. Nationwide excels in this area, offering a seamless claims process and a dedicated team to assist you when you need it most.

Their dedication to customer needs surpasses basic coverage. Nationwide offers coverage for additions, alterations, fixtures, improvements, and installations, ensuring your investment is comprehensively protected.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Inclusive insurance
  • Budget-friendly rates
  • Outstanding customer service
  • Not the best for inexpensive properties
  • Potential for extra charges
  • Limited discount options vedssqzs

Best For Discounts

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Travelers Insurance is now a preferred option for condo insurance in Indiana, especially for those seeking substantial discounts. They offer various ways to save, ensuring their policies stay budget-friendly while still providing comprehensive coverage.

One of the most attractive discount avenues is the multi-policy option. When homeowners combine their condo insurance with a Travelers auto policy, they can save up to 15%. This approach simplifies insurance administration and provides significant savings.

Additionally, Travelers offers further discount opportunities for homeowners utilizing eligible smart or connected home technology. This illustrates the company’s dedication to encouraging and compensating proactive efforts in home maintenance and security.

Travelers is a standout option for Indiana condo owners, thanks to its extensive coverage options and discount offerings. Additionally, Travelers has been recognized for providing more economical home insurance rates than most competitors, while still offering comparable coverage options.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Cost-effective rates
  • Financial security
  • Bundling possibilities
  • Limited choices me others
  • Dog breed restrictions possible
  • More frequent complaints from customers

Best For High-Value Condos

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For owners of luxury condos in Indiana, Chubb stands out as a premier insurance provider. Chubb is renowned for its excellent service and specialized coverage for wealthy policyholders, offering extensive coverage limits and a host of perks.

Created for high net-worth families, the Masterpiece policy provides extended replacement cost options, ensuring full coverage for your valuable property.

Not only does Chubb offer expansive coverage, but it also provides unique benefits like cyber protection and identity theft coverage. Focused on addressing the special needs of high-net-worth households, Chubb delivers top-tier insurance solutions for affluent condo owners in Indiana.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Superior customer care
  • Extra coverage options available
  • Few complaints
  • Rates higher than average
  • Not accredited by the BBB
  • May not suit moderately priced condos

Best Runner-Up

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Amica stands out as a premier choice for comprehensive condo coverage in Indiana. Renowned for its superior customer service and diverse coverage options, Amica offers a smooth insurance experience. By bundling condo and car insurance, policyholders can save up to 20%.

With very competitive rates, Amica outperforms Allstate in terms of lower monthly costs. Additionally, Amica’s low complaint rate reflects its high customer satisfaction. The Platinum Choice Home Coverage offers strong protection by combining various types of coverage for your condo.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Offers multiple coverage options
  • Customers are highly pleased
  • Financially strong insurance provider
  • Above-average rates for premiums
  • Does not pay out dividends
  • AM Best rating is still strong, although downgraded in 2017

How Much Is Condo Insurance In Indiana?

To help you decide wisely, here are several expanded comparison charts:

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By City

Below is a table detailing the average annual and monthly condo insurance costs in the ten largest cities in Indiana:

City Average Annual Rate Average Monthly Rate
Indianapolis $480 $40
Fort Wayne $500 $42
Evansville $450 $37
South Bend $524 $43
Carmel $550 $46
Fishers $546 $45
Bloomington $534 $44
Hammond $570 $47
Gary $467 $38
Lafayette $456 $38

These estimated rates can vary depending on factors such as your condo’s specific location, its structural features, and the coverage amount you desire.

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Building Property Limits

When it comes to condo insurance, customization is key. The coverage you need depends on the value of your property and possessions. To help you decide, here’s a comparison chart of average monthly condo insurance rates in Indiana based on building property limits:

Building Property Limit Average Annual Rate
$40,000 $755
$60,000 $908
$80,000 $1,115
$100,000 $1,324

These rates are estimates and may vary depending on factors such as your condo’s specific location, its structural aspects, and the level of coverage you require.

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Company

This table outlines the average annual rates from ten significant national insurance companies providing condo insurance in Indiana:

Insurance Company Average Annual Rate
State Farm $751
Allstate $802
Liberty Mutual $853
USAA $704
Progressive $905
Nationwide $886
Farmers $1007
Travelers $828
Erie $769
American Family $9510

These rates are approximate and can differ due to factors like your condo’s location, its structural features, and the coverage amount you need. The lowest rate may not provide the best value. Look for a policy that balances affordable rates, comprehensive coverage, excellent customer service, and financial stability.

How To Find The Best Condo Insurance Company For You

Putting in the time and effort to find quality condo insurance that meets your needs is crucial. Your condo is likely your most valuable asset, so protecting it and your belongings is essential for your family’s long-term financial security.

Use these five clear steps to identify the best policy for yourself:

  1. Research condo insurers online and shortlist three companies you feel comfortable with.
  2. Determine the coverage limits you need.
  3. Request quotes from the three chosen insurers.
  4. Choose a carrier by comparing coverage, customer feedback, financial strength, discounts, and rates.
  5. Fill out and submit your application for coverage.

To secure quality condo insurance in Indiana, compare multiple quotes side-by-side. Obtain multiple quotes now with Insuranceopedia.

How To Get An Online Condo Insurance Quote In Indiana

To expedite the process of acquiring an online insurance quote in Indiana, utilize a website that can supply multiple quotes at the same time, facilitating convenient side-by-side comparison, like Insuranceopedia.

When seeking an online quote, you’ll be prompted to provide certain information:

  • If your condo is damaged, the amount you’ll need to rebuild it with similar materials is termed as the condo replacement cost.
  • Personal property value: The maximum coverage you’ll receive for personal property depends on the value of your personal belongings.
  • Personal information: Be prepared to provide your name, address, insurance background, the number of people in your condo, and additional information.
  • Details about your condo: When your condo was built, its size, the materials used for the exterior, any security devices in place, and additional relevant details.

What Does Condo Insurance Cover In Indiana?

Known as HO6 insurance, a typical condo insurance policy in Indiana covers the interior of the condominium, including installed fixtures, appliances, and personal items. This policy protects against damage to the unit’s walls, floors, and cabinets.

Moreover, it covers personal property, offering protection for your belongings from theft or damage. Many policies also include loss assessment coverage, typically starting at $1,000, which can be increased with an endorsement.

How Much Condo Insurance Is Required In Indiana?

In Indiana, condo insurance isn’t a legal necessity, but it is commonly required by mortgage lenders and condo associations. The typical policy offers coverage from $100,000 to $500,000.

How Much Condo Insurance Do I Need In Indiana?

To decide how much condo insurance to get in Indiana, consider factors like the value of your belongings, the condo’s interior structures, and the master insurance policy of your HOA. It is recommended that your insurance includes at least $2,000 in loss assessment coverage for losses in common areas.

How To Save Money On Indiana Condo Insurance

If you own a condo in Indiana, raising your deductible is a key strategy to lower your insurance costs. This will cut your premium but increase the amount you pay if you need to make a claim. Balance the deductible with your financial situation.

Fortifying your condo against disasters is a smart strategy to lower your insurance premiums in Indiana. Enhancements like storm shutters and better security systems not only protect your home but can also earn you discounts on insurance.

Factors That Impact The Cost Of Your Condo Insurance Policy

Here are four primary factors that affect how much you pay for condo insurance in Indiana:

Location of Your Condo

One of the primary factors affecting condo insurance costs is location. Condos in high-risk areas for natural disasters, such as hurricanes, floods, or wildfires, tend to have higher premiums. Indiana’s susceptibility to hurricanes leads to higher insurance rates.

Age and Construction Type of Your Condo

Insurance costs for condos are influenced by the age and construction type of the property. Older condos with outdated wiring, plumbing, or heating systems are more likely to incur damage, leading to higher insurance premiums. Additionally, less durable construction materials can result in increased insurance costs.

Replacement Cost of Your Condo

Your condo insurance cost is also influenced by the replacement cost, which is the expense to rebuild your home entirely. If the replacement cost is high, expect higher insurance premiums.

Claims History

The cost of your condo insurance can be influenced by your claims history. Frequent claims may lead insurers to consider you a higher risk and charge more, while a clean claims record can result in lower premiums.


How much is condo insurance in Indiana?

In Indiana, condo insurance typically costs $465 per year, or $40 monthly. However, actual rates can vary greatly based on location, coverage amount, and the policyholder’s claims history.

How does condo insurance work?

Condo insurance in Indiana averages around $1,457 annually, translating to $121 monthly. However, rates can differ widely due to factors like location, coverage levels, and the insured’s claims history.


Go back to top