Best Condo Insurance In New York For 2024

The best condo insurance in New York is from Nationwide.

min read
Updated: 15 March 2024
Written by
Doug Schaffer
On this page Open

While condo insurance won’t prevent damage to your New York condominium and belongings, it provides a financial safety net amidst the unpredictable. So obtaining sufficient coverage is crucial for safeguarding you and your family’s future and ensuring your peace of mind.

As a resident of New York, you know it has its fair share of extreme weather. Imagine if you woke up to weather damage to your condo and didn’t have the proper insurance coverage. You’d have to cover the damages out-of-pocket, or worse, lose your condo. Either way, you’ll be overwhelmed financially and emotionally.

I’ve seen this precise situation happen to many condo owners in my 13 years working as a licensed insurance agent. That’s why I can’t emphasize enough the importance of getting a condo insurance policy that protects you against all potential risks, from theft to natural disasters.

This guide contains relevant information to put you on the right track to finding the best condo insurance in The Big Apple.

Best Condo Insurance Companies In New York, 2024

Best Condo Insurance, New York, 2024

Compare The Best Condo Insurance Companies In New York

Overall Rating Best For A.M Best Rating J.D Power Rating Get A Quote
Nationwide
4.9

Overall

A+

816

Instant Quote
Amica
4.8

Runner-Up

A+

849

Instant Quote
Travelers
4.6

Discounts

A

794

Instant Quote
Chubb
4.7

High-Value Condos

A++

809

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Our Methodology

To determine which condo insurance companies are the best in New York, I analyzed and compared each company's AM Best financial strength ratings and customer satisfaction ranking by J.D. Power. I also rated the providers based on professional and consumer review sources and my experience selling condo insurance in New York as a licensed property and casualty agent.

35

Quotes Analyzed

19

Brands Reviewed

15+

Years Of Experience

30+

Research Hours

The Best Condo Insurance Companies In New York


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Nationwide provides comprehensive and customized coverages, ensuring condo owners are adequately protected. From covering your personal property like furniture and clothing to reimbursing you for the extra costs of living elsewhere following a covered loss to your condo, they offer several necessary coverages.

Moreover, if you identify any coverage gaps in Nationwide’s standard HO-6 policy, there are a number of add-ons you can get to enhance your protection. These include coverage for any improvements and betterments you make to your condo.

Nationwide also has a committed customer service team and a superior claims handling process that ensures fast and fair claims resolutions in your hour of need.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Good average rates
  • Ample coverage options
  • Top-notch customer service
Drawbacks
  • Potential extra costs
  • Limited discount opportunities
  • Not ideal for low-value condominiums

Best Runner-Up

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Amica’s extensive coverage options and highly rated customer service have earned it a name in the insurance industry. Condo owners in The Big Apple can count on the company for robust protection of their units and personal property and a seamless customer experience.

Amica offers a Platinum Choice Home policy that includes additional protections beyond those provided by a standard condo insurance policy. Additionally, policyholders can bundle their condo insurance with their auto insurance for a chance to save on their insurance costs by up to 20%.

Cost-wise, Amica condo insurance is not as expensive. For instance, compared to Allstate, their monthly rates are considerably lower. And as for customer satisfaction, they perform notably well, boasting low complaint levels.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Wide variety of coverage
  • Strong financial rating
  • High customer satisfaction ratings
Drawbacks
  • Above average rates
  • Dividend policies are not available nationwide
  • AM Best rating downgraded in 2017

Best For Discounts

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Of the insurance providers we’ve rated in this guide, Travelers is the best for condo insurance discounts in New York. They offer numerous discounts, including a multi-policy discount, where condo owners can save up to 15% by bundling their car and condo insurance. Insurance bundling also has the benefit of making it easier to manage your policies.

You can also qualify for a discount for installing smart home technology in your condominium. The insurer views policyholders with smart home devices as having a lower risk of filing claims, thereby rewarding them with lower rates.

The many saving opportunities Travelers provides make their condo insurance policies affordable, meaning condo owners don’t have to skimp on coverage. In addition to their competitive rates, the company’s broad range of coverage options is also noteworthy.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Allow policy bundling
  • Competitive rates
  • Financial stable insurer
Drawbacks
  • May put a ban on certain dog breeds
  • Higher complaints than some of the competition
  • Limited availability

Best For High-Value Condos

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Chubb targets owners of high-end condominiums in New York and other states. Their condo insurance policies feature specialized coverages, high coverage limits, and a multitude of perks fit for affluent policyholders.

Chubb’s Masterpiece policy provides extended replacement cost coverage for your condominium and its contents. The purpose of the cover is to insure your condo and valuables to their full replacement value.

The insurance company also offers various additional offerings that serve the unique needs of high-net-worth individuals. These include coverages for identity theft and cyber-related attacks.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Several add-on coverage options
  • Excellent customer service
  • Low number of complaints
Drawbacks
  • Only for high-value condos
  • More expensive than most competitors
  • Not accredited by the BBB

How Much Is Condo Insurance In New York?

To aid in your decision-making, here are three tables containing condo insurance cost data for you to compare.

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Building Property Limits

Below is a comparison of the average monthly cost of condo insurance in New York for different building limits.

Building Property Limit Average Annual Rate
$40,000 $550
$60,000 $610
$80,000 $715
$100,000 $900

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By Company

Here’s what ten condo insurance companies in New York charge for condo insurance annually.

Insurance Company Average Annual Rate
AIG $1,035
State Farm $298
Farmers $871
American Family $431
Chubb $$712
Travelers $450
Nationwide $710
Allstate $500

The Average Cost Of Condo Insurance By City

And finally, the average annual and monthly condo insurance rates in 10 of New York’s cities.

City Average Annual Rate
Yonkers $516
New York City $641
Ithaca $494
Rochester $450
Syracuse $523
Saratoga Springs $473
White plains $540
Utica $480
Warwick $510

The rates shown in the above tables may vary significantly based on many factors, including location, coverage amount, and structural features. That said, cost shouldn’t be your only consideration when choosing condo insurance. The ideal policy should balance affordability, comprehensive coverage, financial strength, and customer satisfaction.

How To Get An Online Condo Insurance Quote In New York

Comparing condo insurance quotes from multiple insurers is the best way to find excellent rates without compromising on coverage. To get personalized quotes—whether online, by phone, or in person—you’ll be asked a few questions. These include:

  • What is your name?
  • What is your address?
  • What is your insurance history?
  • What is the square footage of your condo?
  • How many people live in the residence?
  • When was it built?
  • What is the exterior constructed of?
  • What is your condo’s rebuilding cost?
  • What is the value of your personal property?
  • What protective devices do you have?

Factors That Impact The Cost Of Your Condo Insurance Policy

Condo insurance companies set your insurance rates by taking into consideration various factors, including:

  • Amount of dwelling coverage: this part of your policy pays to rebuild your condominium if it gets damaged by a covered loss. The higher the coverage limits, the more your condo insurance will likely cost.
  • Your condo location: if situated in a high-crime neighborhood or disaster-prone area, your premiums will reflect those risks. Extreme weather events like hurricanes and floods are becoming more frequent in New York City, which could cause insurance costs to spike.
  • The age of your condo and the materials that make it up: older condos are more likely to have issues due to dated plumbing, electrical, and heating systems, which makes them more expensive to insure. Similarly, condos built with durable materials attract lower premiums.
  • Your personal claims history: insurance providers believe policyholders with a history of filing claims to be high-risk and typically charge them higher rates. On the flip side, a clean claims history may qualify you for a claims-free discount.

How To Save Money On New York Condo Insurance

One of the ways you can lower your condo insurance costs in NYC is by raising your deductible. Generally, by increasing the amount of your deductible, you will pay less for coverage but more out-of-pocket on a claim. For this reason, you must first consider your financial situation before choosing a deductible amount.

Your insurer may offer discounts for select home improvements that minimize the risks of property theft and damage. So you can also save money on your condo policy by, for example, adding storm shutters and installing a home alarm system.

What Does Condo Insurance Cover In New York?

A condo insurance policy, also known as a HO-6 policy, helps pay for repairs to the interior structures of your condo’s unit. These include inner walls, cabinets, fixtures, and flooring. It also protects your belongings and appliances, reimbursing you if any get damaged, stolen, or lost.

Additionally, most condo insurance policies come with a loss assessment coverage limit of $1,000, which you can increase with an endorsement. The coverage protects you against damage or injury claims related to common areas.

How To Find The Best Condo Insurance Company For You

Your condominium is most likely your most valuable asset, and as such, obtaining condo insurance protects not just your unit and its contents but also your finances. Follow this step-by-step process to purchase the best policy.

  1. Determine how much coverage you need.
  2. Do an online search for condo insurance companies in New York.
  3. Review each company’s coverage types, professional and consumer reviews, financial strength, and extra benefits like discounts.
  4. Request and compare condo insurance quotes from three providers that meet your needs. A quote comparison website like Insuranceopedia can make this step much quicker.
  5. Choose a provider and start your application for condo insurance.

FAQs

How does condo insurance work?

Condo insurance works in conjunction with your condo association’s master policy to provide sufficient coverage for your condo’s needs. The policy protects the interior of your condominium and personal belongings from covered perils and shields you from liability claims.

How much condo insurance do I need in New York?

When it comes to condo insurance, one size does not fit all. To determine how much condo insurance you need, adjust the amounts of the basic coverage types in a standard condo policy to fit your needs. These coverages include dwelling coverage, personal property coverage, liability coverage, and additional living expenses coverage.

How much condo insurance is required in New York?

It’s not mandatory for condo owners in New York to carry condo insurance. However, your condo association and mortgage lender will most likely require you to purchase a policy. Most policies generally include a minimum of $100,000 and a maximum of $500,000 in liability coverage.

How much is condo insurance in New York?

Condo owners in New York pay an average of  $121 per month or $1,457 per year for condo insurance. These rates vary depending on various factors, including your location, coverage limits, claims history, and your association’s master policy.

Sources

Go back to top