Best Health Insurance Companies In Oklahoma

min read -
Updated: 21 December 2025
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

With 15 years in health insurance and 12 in Oklahoma, I’ve found that Aetna is a leading choice for those seeking quality coverage. Their plans strike a balance between cost and benefits, making them a reliable option.

Oklahomans pay an average of $498 per month for Aetna’s Silver plans, though actual costs depend on factors like age and location. A 40-year-old, for example, might see a premium of around $573.

Aetna’s strong provider network and perks, such as CVS Health discounts, add value. They also receive fewer complaints than many competitors, showing their dedication to customer satisfaction.

Best Health Insurance Companies In Oklahoma 2025

aetna
Best Overall - Aetna
blue cross
Best PPO/HMO Plans - Blue Cross / Blue Shield

Compare The Best Health Insurance Companies In Oklahoma

Overall Rating Best Suited For J.D. Power Rating AM Best Rating Online Buying Experience
Aetna
4

Best Overall

616

A (Excellent)

9.7/10

Blue Cross/Blue Shield
3

Best PPO/HMO Plans

593

A (Excellent)

9.5/10

Humana
3

Best Provider Network

582

A- (Excellent)

9.6/10

Cigna
4

Best Policyholder Service

581

A (Excellent)

9.7/10

MetLife
3

Best Add-On Coverages

N/A

A+ (Superior)

9.5/10

Scroll to see comparisons

Best Health Insurance Companies in Oklahoma 2025


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For Oklahomans, Aetna is the best health insurance provider, offering affordable premiums, a vast provider network, and comprehensive coverage. It’s an excellent option for individuals, families, and businesses.

Aetna’s plan options—HMOs, PPOs, and EPOs—cater to different healthcare needs. Virtual healthcare and wellness programs further enhance accessibility.

With its collaboration with CVS Health, Aetna ensures additional savings on prescriptions and wellness services while maintaining competitive pricing.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Favorable pricing compared to other insurance providers.
  • A large circle of service providers scattered throughout Oklahoma.
  • CVS affiliations allow for discounts on medication.
Drawbacks
  • A referral is typically needed for specialist appointments through certain plans.
  • There are limited short-duration health insurance plans.
  • Calling customer support during busy hours may result in longer wait times.

Best PPO-HMO Plans

Overall Rating
3

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Oklahomans looking for comprehensive health insurance with broad provider access will find Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) of Oklahoma a strong choice. Their PPO and HMO plans come with robust in-network benefits and access to care both statewide and nationwide.

BCBS Oklahoma plans include various deductible and co-pay structures, plus perks like telemedicine, wellness benefits, and chronic disease programs. PPO plans allow for greater provider flexibility, while HMOs are a cost-effective option.

With the BlueCard® program, BCBS ensures seamless healthcare access across multiple states, making it ideal for frequent travelers or those needing extensive provider options.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Enjoy nationwide service availability through the BlueCard® program.
  • PPO and HMO plans come with flexible options.
  • A reputable source for managing claims and offering outstanding assistance to clients.
Drawbacks
  • Prices that are on the higher side compared to several competitors.
  • Some budget plans have a confined selection of healthcare options.
  • Accessing care from non-network providers frequently results in higher bills.

Best Provider Network

Overall Rating
3

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For Oklahomans seeking extensive healthcare provider access, Humana offers one of the best networks. Their coverage includes a wide range of hospitals, specialists, and primary care doctors, ensuring members receive top-tier care without out-of-network complications.

Humana is particularly known for its Medicare Advantage plans, which are highly rated among seniors. Their employer-sponsored plans also provide valuable wellness initiatives and preventive care benefits.

Although Humana’s individual plans are somewhat limited, their group and Medicare plans make them one of the top choices in Oklahoma for seniors and employees.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • A robust network of providers results in fewer out-of-network complications.
  • A range of excellent Medicare Advantage plan options.
  • Resilient programs dedicated to health and prevention.
Drawbacks
  • Availability of health plans for individuals is restricted.
  • There are insurance options that require higher-than-normal premiums.
  • You may notice that customer service’s response times are not very fast.

Best Policyholder Service

Overall Rating
4

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Oklahomans looking for a health insurer with excellent customer service and quick claims processing should consider Cigna. Their online platform is user-friendly, and their support team ensures members get the help they need.

Cigna’s comprehensive plans include worldwide emergency care, making them a strong choice for travelers. Their mental health benefits are also extensive, supporting members who need behavioral health services.

For an easy and reliable healthcare experience, Cigna is a top provider in Oklahoma.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Great support for customers along with claims management.
  • Positive mental state and the advantages of telemedicine access.
  • Global options for those who travel regularly.
Drawbacks
  • Certain plans could lead to increased personal outlay.
  • Individuals may have to spend a lot on PPO plans.
  • Individuals who are self-employed have a reduced selection of plans available.

Best Add-On Coverages

Overall Rating
3

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
7/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
7/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

MetLife provides supplemental insurance coverage, including dental, vision, disability, and extra health benefits. While they don’t offer primary health insurance, their plans effectively complement existing policies.

Their supplemental coverage is ideal for families and individuals looking to reduce medical expenses and gain additional financial security. MetLife’s add-ons help cover out-of-pocket costs.

For policyholders who need enhanced coverage, MetLife’s supplemental options provide excellent support.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Great as an additional insurance solution.
  • Credited with a solid financial track record.
  • Low-cost choices for extra insurance plans.
Drawbacks
  • Limited selection of fundamental health insurance options.
  • Not as enriched as services from full-service entities
  • Certain add-ons could come with a waiting timeline before their benefits are accessible.

Cheapest Health Insurance Companies In Oklahoma

If you want affordable health coverage in Oklahoma, it’s important to compare different plans. Here are five insurance providers with some of the lowest Silver plan premiums on average.

Insurance Company Average Monthly Premium (Silver Plan)
Blue Cross Blue Shield $390
MetLife $440
Humana $438
Aetna $473
Cigna $484

Heads Up: The rates listed here are based on a 40-year-old’s average premium. Your actual cost may be affected by age, location, and subsidy qualification.

Looking for a more affordable plan? ACA subsidies can help—many Oklahomans qualify for financial aid to lower their insurance payments.

Factors Affecting Health Insurance Costs In Oklahoma

  • Age: Older policyholders typically pay higher premiums due to increased health risks.
  • Location: Living in a city can mean higher costs, while rural areas may have fewer provider options.
  • Coverage Level: The more benefits a plan offers, the more expensive it is.
  • Family Size: Insurance premiums increase as dependents are added.
  • Tobacco Use: Smokers pay extra due to health concerns.
  • Insurance Provider: Each insurer has its own pricing structure and network agreements.

Common Health Insurance Terms

Health insurance terms can be tough to decode. Here are some important ones that Oklahomans may run into.

Premium – The set amount you pay each month for your health insurance.
Deductible – The amount you must pay yourself before your insurance starts helping with costs.
Copay – A fixed fee you pay for doctor visits, prescriptions, or other medical services.
Coinsurance – The percentage of costs you and your insurer share after your deductible is met.
Out-of-Pocket Maximum – The most you’ll have to pay in a year before your insurance covers everything else.
HMO – A type of plan that requires referrals and in-network doctors but is usually cheaper.
PPO – A plan that lets you see any doctor without referrals, but costs more in premiums.

A solid understanding of these terms can help you choose the right health coverage.

How To Save On Health Insurance In Oklahoma

Health insurance in Oklahoma doesn’t have to break the bank. Picking the right plan, seeking financial assistance, and making smart healthcare choices can help reduce costs. Here’s how.

  • Select an HDHP: Lower premiums and an HSA can help you save on medical expenses.
  • Compare Plans on the Marketplace: Researching options can help you find the best fit.
  • Look into ACA Subsidies: If you qualify, your costs could be significantly reduced.
  • Use Workplace Health Plans: Employer-sponsored insurance is often the most affordable choice.
  • Stick with In-Network Doctors: This avoids unnecessary extra charges.
  • Use Free Preventive Healthcare Services: Many plans cover wellness checks at no cost.
  • Choose Generic Medications: They work the same as brand names but cost much less.

A smart insurance choice means Oklahomans can get great coverage without breaking the bank.

How Much Does Health Insurance Cost In Oklahoma?

Health insurance in Oklahoma is priced based on factors like age, coverage level, and region. In 2025, Silver plans cost around $510 per month, Bronze plans average $400, and Gold plans cost $515. Catastrophic plans, meant for younger, healthy individuals, cost about $375.

A 40-year-old can expect to pay roughly $573 for a Silver plan. Many Oklahomans can qualify for ACA subsidies, reducing their premium costs significantly.

Average Cost By Coverage Level

Your health insurance premium in Oklahoma will depend on the plan tier you choose. The four coverage levels—Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum—each offer different combinations of monthly costs and out-of-pocket expenses.

Bronze plans have lower premiums but higher deductibles, while Platinum plans cost more per month but reduce out-of-pocket spending. Below is a summary of the average monthly premium for each tier.

Coverage Level Average Monthly Premium
Bronze $400
Silver $510
Gold $515
Platinum $600

Average Cost By Family Size

How much you pay for health insurance in Oklahoma depends not only on the type of plan but also on the number of covered individuals. Individual plans have lower premiums, but adding dependents increases costs. Family plans, which include spouses and children, adjust pricing accordingly. Below is an overview of average monthly premiums for different family sizes.

Family Size Average Monthly Premium
Individual (Single Adult) $573
Couple (Two Adults) $1,146
Family of Three $1,430
Family of Four $1,715
Family of Five $2,000

Average Cost Of Health Insurance Plans By City

The cost of health insurance in Oklahoma is affected by the city you live in, with variations based on healthcare expenses, competition among providers, and local health trends. Below is an overview of average monthly Silver plan premiums across five major cities.

City Average Monthly Premium (Silver Plan)

Norman

$478

Broken Arrow

$479

Edmond

$472

Oklahoma City

$478

Tulsa

$477

How To Sign Up For A Health Insurance Policy

The process of securing health insurance in Oklahoma is easy, but it’s important to stay on top of deadlines.

  • Check If You Qualify – Look into employer insurance, government programs, or ACA coverage.
  • Create a Marketplace Account – Register online to view plan options.
  • Compare Plans Side by Side – Look at costs, coverage, and providers.
  • See If You’re Eligible for Assistance – You might get subsidies to lower costs.
  • Select a Health Plan – Choose one that suits your needs and budget.
  • Finalize Your Enrollment – Submit your application and required paperwork.
  • Pay Your First Premium – Insurance starts after your payment is processed.

Marriage, job loss, and other big life events can make you eligible for health insurance enrollment outside the usual period.

Health Insurance Coverage Levels

With four tiers of health insurance available, Oklahomans can compare costs and benefits to select a plan that suits their needs.

Bronze – Pay the least per month, but the most when you get care. Ideal for people with few medical needs.
Silver – Mid-range premiums and benefits. Good for those qualifying for subsidies.
Gold – Higher monthly cost, but lower costs when visiting the doctor.
Platinum – The most expensive plan, but the lowest out-of-pocket expenses.

Choosing the right insurance plan is a balance between your healthcare needs, what you can afford, and how much financial risk you’re comfortable with.

Health Insurance Options In Oklahoma If You Have A Low Income

Various health assistance programs are available to Oklahomans who need affordable coverage options.

Medicaid – A federal and state program that provides free or low-cost insurance to qualifying individuals, including children, pregnant women, and people with disabilities.
CHIP – Covers children in low-income families who don’t qualify for Medicaid.
ACA Subsidies – Financial assistance that helps lower monthly premiums and healthcare costs.
FQHCs – Health clinics that adjust fees based on a patient’s income.
Charity Care – Hospitals and clinics that help uninsured individuals with medical expenses.
Short-Term Plans – Temporary health coverage with limited benefits.

Finding the right healthcare option can make medical treatment more affordable and accessible.

Our Methodology

How We Rate Oklahoma Health Insurance Providers

We use these key factors for an unbiased assessment:

• Cost – We compare premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket expenses.

• Customer Service – We check reviews, complaints, and responsiveness.

• Claims Handling – We evaluate how efficiently claims are processed.

• Coverage Options – We analyze plan benefits, provider networks, and flexibility.

• Financial Stability – We ensure companies can pay claims reliably.

• Added Benefits – We factor in perks like telehealth and digital tools.

75

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

25

Brands Reviewed

35+

Research Hours

Sources

About Bob Phillips

Having spent over fifteen years helping people plan their lives financially, Bob mastered many different financial products to help people achieve their financial goals, including life insurance, disability insurance, mutual funds, and stocks and bonds.
Read Full Bio
Go back to top