Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For 2024

If you’re seeking the most affordable vehicle insurance in Michigan, State Farm stands out from the pack as a leading provider. Known for its reasonable premiums and reliable service, this insurance carrier offers the best value for both minimum and comprehensive policies.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 20 May 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

In this extensive guide, we compare different car insurance options while focusing on affordability. With 10+ years of experience in studying the intricacies of auto insurance policies, I’m sharing my findings to help you make sense of what can be a confusing market.

I’ve thoroughly analyzed many top car insurance providers, studying them on multiple parameters so you get the information you need to make good choices.

Remember, focusing solely on price can end up being more expensive over time – especially in a state presenting the driving challenges that Michigan does. My goal is to provide you with the information and advice you require to make better decisions on car insurance coverage.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Michigan

Cheapest Car Insurance, Michigan, 2024

Our Methodology

Leveraging thorough research that touches on vital perspectives like policyholder service ratings, product options, cost, and a look at different online review sites and user experience, I've put together a thorough guide on the state of affairs as per car insurance providers in Michigan. I have 15 years of professional experience as a licensed casualty insurance agent in Michigan, many interactions with representatives from many insurance companies, and insights obtained from firsthand experience purchasing car insurance in Michigan.


Quotes Analyzed


Hours Of Research


Years Of Industry Experience


Brands Reviewed

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For Minimum Coverage: GEICO

GEICO offers the lowest-cost minimum coverage auto insurance, with average monthly premiums of $52.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
GEICO $52 $620
Progressive $80 $963
Farmers $112 $1,343
State Farm $161 $1,933
Bristol West $177 $2,120

Liability-only coverage in auto insurance represents the most basic level of protection. While full coverage is often a better idea, minimum coverage meets the requirements of the state of Michigan. Minimum coverage includes Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Property Damage Liability (PDL).

PIP foots medical care payments and lost salary for you and any passengers, regardless of who caused the accident, while PDL covers expenses related to damage to another person’s property because of an accident you caused. This coverage is a good idea for motorists seeking coverage that is affordable and meets Michigan’s legal requirements.

However, it’s vital to consider that liability-only insurance has certain limitations – particularly in a scenario involving a major accident. Yes, minimum coverage meets state law. But if you go that route to save money, you may regret it in a situation where you run into problems.

For instance, minimum coverage lacks coverage for collision or comprehensive insurance. That means you’ll have to shoulder responsibility for damages to your vehicle if there’s an accident, theft, or natural disaster. So, you need to think things through before deciding on an insurance policy.

Think about your specific situation, your risk-tolerance level, and if you might need coverage over and above the minimum coverage offered in Michigan. Doing this will ensure you get the coverage you need on the road.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For Full Coverage: Hastings Mutual

Hastings Mutual has the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Michigan. You can get coverage for around $97 a month.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Hastings Mutual $97 $1,152
Geico $100 $1,183
Secura $112 $1,378
Wolverine Mutual $122 $1,423
Fremont $150 $1,798

Comprehensive auto insurance includes a more thorough range of protection, compared to liability-only coverage. So, it’s a good choice for many drivers. This sort of policy usually brings together comprehensive and collision insurance to establish a strong safety net. Comprehensive coverage includes non-collision related instances like theft, vandalism, and natural disasters, while collision insurance covers damages to your car if there’s an accident, regardless of who is at fault.

This multi-layered approach ensures that people are protected in the event of various issues ranging from collisions to unexpected environmental damages. Comprehensive coverage is a good idea for people with newer model cars or high-value cars since these cars can require costlier repairs or replacements.

Full coverage costs more than minimum coverage, but this price boost offers much more protection. For people who own newer or high-end cars, comprehensive coverage is sometimes a requirement to protect their investment.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For Good Drivers: Secura

Secura provide the cheapest insurance policy for good drivers, with an average monthly premium of $83.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Secura $83 $991
USAA $107 $1,286
Geico $127 $1,527
Hastings Mutual $135 $1,621
Auto-Owners Insurance $140 $1,678

Good drivers, typically people with great driving records, are usually rewarded with lower auto insurance premiums. Insurers look at risk based on a driver’s history, and drivers without any violations or collisions fit within the low-risk category. This desired risk profile is a good fit for those who have a history of responsible and safe driving. Such drivers are less likely to file claims down the road.

Insurance companies, in turn, are more likely to offer such motorists better monthly rates, reflecting the lower financial risk they represent. For people who regularly follow traffic laws, avoid collisions, and demonstrate overall good driving behavior, this means big savings on car insurance coverage over time.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For Seniors: Hastings Mutual

Seniors can expect to pay about $96 per month for cheap auto insurance, using Hastings Mutual.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Hastings Mutual $96 $1,148
Wolverine Mutual $100 $1,201
Farmers $105 $1,260
Geico $106 $1,275
Secura $111 $1,328

Seniors in Michigan can get some great premiums because of some factors that work for rather than against them. Age can play a big role in their car insurance rates. As motorists get older, their reflexes and driving skills can potentially decline. That said, many seniors continue to maintain spotless driving records even as they continue getting older.

Insurance companies usually acknowledge the benefits that come with greater driving experience, which means seniors can secure competitive rates. A clean driving record with no accidents or traffic tickets can convince insurers to offer lower rates to drivers. As well, some car insurance providers recognize the maturity and skill that come with age. Seniors are often responsible behind the wheel and don’t take the types of risks some younger drivers might.

Further boosting the appeal for elderly drivers, some insurers offer price cuts specifically tailored to this demographic. These price reductions can be based on different criteria, such as the motorist’s age, how often the vehicle is used, and the successful completion of senior driving safety programs.

Many car insurance providers encourage elderly drivers to take defense driving courses – and there are sometimes incentives to encourage them to do so. One big one is a reduction in their car insurance premiums. Such programs are designed to refresh driving skills and know-how, which can lead to safer driving habits.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For Young Drivers In Michigan

In Michigan, young adult motorists usually get lower car insurance premiums compared to their teenager counterparts. The reason for the pricing difference is the age difference. Younger drivers tend to take more risks than older drivers, so age does matter.

Young adults are less likely than teenage motorists to file claims with insurers, which means the former are less likely to be involved in car accidents. What this means is that insurance providers reduce premiums because of the better safety records and lower rates of claims from these more experienced motorists.

Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance For 16-Year-Olds: GEICO

GEICO has the lowest-cost rates for 16-year-olds, with an average monthly rate of $403.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
GEICO $403 $4,832
Nationwide $458 $5,496
State Farm $495 $5,893
Farmers $754 $8,994
Allstate $763 $9,158

Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance For 17-Year-Olds: GEICO

GEICO offers the cheapest premiums for 17-year-olds, with an average rate of $350.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
GEICO $350 $4,210
Nationwide $421 $5,082
State Farm $445 $5,372
Farmers $617 $7,390
Allstate $642 $7,701

Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance For 18-Year-Olds: Erie

Erie Insurance offers the lowest rates for 18-year-olds, with an average monthly cost of $252.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Erie Insurance $252 $3,020
Auto-Owners Insurance $258 $3,094
Geico $260 $3,115
State Farm $273 $3,281
American Family Insurance $302 $3,625

Cheapest Michigan Car Insurance For 21-Year-Olds: Progressive

Progressive has the cheapest premiums for 21-year-olds, with average monthly costs of $218.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Progressive $218 $2,620
USAA $225 $2,695
Auto-Owners Insurance $293 $3,512
Michigan Farm Bureau $409 $4,904
Automobile Club Michigan $418 $5,017

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan For Drivers With Prior Incidents

Drivers in Michigan with a track record of accidents, including collisions, DUIs, or speeding tickets, usually encounter major challenges when seeking affordable auto insurance. These insurers label them as high-risk. This high-risk tag stems from the greater odds of these motorists filing claims in the future. Because of this, insurance companies usually boost costs for such motorists to compensate for the greater risk of payouts.

This is all the more true in Michigan, where the traffic accident rates can be loftier than in other states. The reasoning underpinning this pricing strategy is based on statistical analyses and risk assessment models, which show that a history of driving incidents means a higher odd of future claims.

Cheapest Car Insurance For Drivers With A Speeding Ticket: Progressive

Progressive offers average premiums of $140, making it the most affordable option for motorists with a speeding ticket.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Progressive $140 $1,678
USAA $153 $1,840
Hastings Mutual $156 $1,869
Secura $190 $2,283
GEICO $195 $2,340

Cheapest Auto Insurance For Drivers With An At-Fault Accident: Secura

Secura has average premiums of $114, making it the lowest-cost option for motorists with an at-fault accident.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Secura $114 $1,365
USAA $180 $2,164
Wolverine Mutual $219 $2,628
Progressive $230 $2,756
Allstate $241 $2,892

Most Affordable Auto Insurance For Drivers After A DUI: State Farm

State Farm has average rates of $169, making it the lowest-cost option for people with a DUI on their record.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
State Farm $169 $2,032
Progressive $176 $2,117
USAA $299 $2,314
Secura $259 $3,109
Wolverine Mutual $446 $5,361

Average Cost In Michigan – By Age

Age Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
16 $518 $6,220
17 $514 $6,173
18 $493 $5,912
19 $468 $5,619
21 $393 $4,713
25 $294 $3,532
35 $216 $2,589
45 $205 $2,464
55 $190 $2,280
65 $180 $2,157
75 $263 $3,160

Average Cost In Michigan – By Gender & Marital Status

Gender Marital Status Average Annual Cost
Female Single $2,245
Male Single $2,356
Female Married $3,368
Male Married $3,534

Cheapest Car Insurance In Michigan By City

City Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Holland $137 $1,640
Traverse City $141 $1,689
Grand Rapids $144 $1,723
Kalamazoo $155 $1,862
Kentwood $191 $2,294
Midland $199 $2,385

Minimum Car Insurance Requirement In Michigan

The minimum Michigan auto insurance coverage requirements under state regulations are as follows:

  • PIP: $20,000 or $40,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $10,000 per accident outside Michigan and $1 million inside Michigan

In Michigan, all drivers must have a minimum level of auto insurance to legally operate a vehicle in the state. This requirement is based on the Financial Responsibility Law and the No-Fault Law, intended to ensure that people can cover the expenses associated with vehicle accidents. Specifically, the law requires that drivers obtain two primary types of coverage: Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Property Damage Liability (PDL).

Personal Injury Protection (PIP) is required under Michigan’s status as a no-fault state. If there’s a car accident, each motorist’s insurance provider will pay for their medical costs, regardless of who was at fault. The minimum PIP coverage required in Michigan is $20,000. This coverage also covers lost wages and death benefits. You can see that it offers a financial safety net for customers and their loved ones.

Property Damage Liability (PDL) is Michigan’s other mandatory coverage. It covers damage that the driver or members of their household causes to the property of others in an auto accident. The minimum required coverage for PDL is also $10 per accident outside the state and $1 million inside the state. PDL does not cover the driver’s vehicle damage; it’s only for the damages caused to others’ property.

Car Insurance Discounts In Michigan

While seeking auto insurance, it’s a good idea to look for insurers offering the best discounts for someone in your situation. Speaking with your insurance agent can reveal possible price cuts that you didn’t know about.

Below is more information about different ways you can save money on your car insurance:

  • Multi-policy: Combine multiple policies with a single insurer.
  • Multi-vehicle: Insure more than one vehicle under the same insurance provider.
  • Military: Veterans and active-duty military members can qualify for special discounts.
  • Senior: Elderly drivers who are 55 years old or older can get discounts.
  • Homeowners: People who own homes may qualify for a special cost reduction.
  • Good student: This discount is usually for post-secondary and high school students under 25 who maintain a B average.
  • Driver training: Taking and passing a driver education training course can mean lower premiums.
  • Pay-in-full: Paying for car insurance upfront can result in a price discount.
  • New car: Drivers with cars that are new or almost new – not more than three model years old – can save on insurance.
  • Defensive driving: Successfully completing a defensive driving course can lead to discounts.
  • Good driver: You can cut costs by maintaining a clean driving record (with no at-fault collisions, DUI, or traffic infractions in the last three years).
  • Safe car: Vehicle with the latest safety features like anti-theft technology can lead to lower insurance.
  • Paperless: Documents through email rather than through snail mail can lower costs


How much is car insurance a month in Michigan?

The monthly cost of auto insurance in Michigan depends on various factors. They usually range from about $175 to $333. Things like driving record, type of coverage, and the type of car influence rates.

What is the minimum car insurance one must have in Michigan?

In Michigan, the minimum auto insurance required is Personal Injury Protection (PIP) is $20,000, while the minimum required Property Damage Liability (PDL) is $10,000 outside the state and $1 million inside the state.

Which insurance is better in Michigan?

The “best” insurance provider in Michigan depends on your requirements. Geico and Hastings Mutual are both popular because of their affordability and customer service.


Go back to top