Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For 2024

If you’re seeking out the lowest cost auto insurance coverage in Kentucky, Kentucky Farm Bureau stands out as the premier company. Known for its affordable rates and reliable service, Kentucky Farm Bureau provides the best value for both minimum coverage and comprehensive coverage plans.

min read
Updated: 08 February 2024
Written by
Bob Phillips
On this page Open

In this comprehensive resource, we compare different auto insurance options while focusing on affordability. With 10+ years of experience in analyzing the ins and outs of car insurance coverage, I’ve distilled our findings to assist you in finding your way through this complex segment. My analysis doesn’t merely skim the surface; I’ve comprehensively assessed examined dozens of leading auto insurance businesses, assessing them on different parameters to ensure you obtain the details that matter.

Keep in mind that taking short cuts on auto insurance can be more expensive down the road, particularly in a state with unique driving challenges such as Kentucky. My aim is to give you the information you need to make good decisions that protect your wallet and your peace of mind. So, get ready as Insuranceopedia takes you through the important aspects of selecting the right auto insurance coverage in Kentucky, ensuring you’re adequately covered at a fair price.

 

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Kentucky

Cheapest Car Insurance, Kentucky

Our Methodology

Drawing upon a thorough assessment that includes various facets such as client service ratings, coverage options, cost, and a thorough analysis of different online review sites and user experience, I've put together an in-depth overview of the landscape of vehicle insurance providers in Kentucky. This is a perspective built on facts, honed by 15+ years of personal involvement in the sector as a licensed casualty insurance agent in Kentucky, many discussions with representatives from various insurers, and insights gained from experience purchasing auto insurance in Kentucky.

65

Quotes Analyzed

35+

Hours Of Research

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

22

Brands Reviews

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Kentucky

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Minimum Coverage

Kentucky Farm Bureau offers the lowest-cost liability-only coverage car insurance, with average monthly premiums of $34.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Kentucky Farm Bureau $34 $410
Electric $43 $515
USAA $51 $608
Westfield $55 $659
Geico $61 $732

Liability only coverage in auto insurance is the most fundamental level of protection, meeting the requirements of the state of Kentucky. It includes a couple of key aspects: Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Property Damage Liability (PDL).

PIP covers medical costs and lost income for you and your passengers, regardless of the person who caused an accident, while PDL covers the expenses of damage to another person’s property stemming from an accident you caused. This sort of coverage is attractive to motorists who want coverage that’s affordable and meets state requirements.

But it’s vital to realize that choosing liability-only coverage may leave you exposed, especially in certain collision situations. While it ensures compliance with the laws of the state and offers basic safety coverage, minimum coverage does not cover many situations that more comprehensive policies cover.

For instance, it does not cover collision or comprehensive insurance, which means damages to your own car in the event of a collision or other issues like theft and natural disasters won’t be covered. So, motorists must carefully think about their individual circumstances, the risk level they can tolerate, and if they might require more coverage beyond the state’s minimum requirements to have the best protection.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Full Coverage

Kentucky Farm Bureau has the most affordable full coverage car insurance in Kentucky. You can buy coverage for around $78 a month.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Kentucky Farm Bureau $78 $938
Shelter $152 $1,823
Geico $175 $2,101
USAA $180 $2,154
Nationwide $189 $2,265

Comprehensive auto insurance includes more protection versus liability-only coverage, making it a better option for many motorists. This type of policy usually combines both comprehensive and collision coverage, creating a strong safety net. Full insurance covers non-collision related events like vandalism, theft, and natural disasters, while collision insurance cover damages to your car in the event of a collision, regardless of fault.

This dual-layered strategy ensures that people are safeguarded in many scenarios, from accidents to unexpected environmental damages. Full coverage is particularly recommended for motorists with newer model cars or high-value cars, since these vehicles usually require more costly repairs or replacements.

The cost of comprehensive coverage is usually more than that of liability-only coverage, but this price hike adds a lot more protection. For owners of newer model cars or more costly cars, this type of insurance is not just nice to have but a requirement to protect their investment.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Seniors

Seniors can expect to pay $107 for low-cost auto insurance, using State Farm.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
State Farm $107 $1,283
Kentucky Farm Bureau $108 $1,295
Geico $113 $1,354
Travelers $116 $1,389
Nationwide $117 $1,409

Seniors in Kentucky can obtain affordable premiums for their vehicle insurance, thanks to numerous things that work in their favor. Age can be a big factor in determining insurance rates, with the assumption that as people age, their reflexes behind the steering wheel decline. That’s not an across-the-board rule, however, since many elderly drivers maintain great driving records.

Insurance companies know this and offer experienced elderly drivers reduced rates. A good driving record, with few or zero collisions and traffic violations, can greatly sway insurance providers to offer better terms. Additionally, some insurers recognize the maturity and experience that senior drivers have, viewing elderly drivers as responsible and less likely to participate in risky driving behaviors.

Certain insurance companies offer price cuts specifically tailored to this demographic. These price cuts can be based on different criteria like the person’s age, how often they drive, and the successful completion of a driver safety program. Many insurers encourage elderly drivers to take defensive driving programs, sometimes offering price cuts upon completion. These courses can refresh and update driving skills, contributing to better driving habits.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Drivers With Poor Credit

If you have bad credit, you can find the lowest-cost car insurance with Kentucky Farm Bureau. Premiums are around $312.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Kentucky Farm Bureau $267 $3,204
Travelers $308 $3,696
Geico $363 $4,356
Progressive $384 $4,608
Nationwide $426 $5,112

Credit score plays a major role in the tabulation of auto insurance rates, serving as a primary indicator for insurance companies in determining the risk profile of a motorist. The underlying premise is that people with lower credit scores face a higher likelihood of filing insurance claims, which makes such people high-risk customers from an insurance company’s perspective. This risk assessment leads to higher insurance premiums.

So, people with poor credit scores usually face higher insurance premiums compared to people with better credit scores. The credit score is used to determine a person’s overall responsibility and dependability, extending outside of their driving history to focus on their financial stability.

Despite this trend, the insurance segment does offer some good news for people with shaky credit histories. Certain insurers have tailored their offerings to cater to this segment, offering more competitive premiums that don’t significantly penalize poor credit as much as most policies. These insurance providers often employ a more holistic process in assessing risk, considering things beyond just the credit score.

This can include a person’s history on the road, where they live, and the kind of car insured. For people with bad credit, it’s vital to look around and compare quotes from insurers. They might see that these insurers offer more forgiving pricing structures, making auto insurance more accessible and cost-effective despite their poor credit.

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Young Drivers In Kentucky

In Kentucky, young adult motorists usually benefit from lower-cost vehicle insurance premiums compared to teenage drivers. This difference in pricing is due to the maturation of driving behaviors and a corresponding drop in risk-taking behaviors as people age. Statistically, young adults file fewer claims with insurance companies, a factor that showcases a drop in accident involvement. As a result, insurance providers adjust rates downward, recognizing the good safety records and lower odds of claims from these more experienced motorists.

Cheapest Kentucky Car Insurance For 16-Year-Olds

Shelter has the lowest-cost premiums for 16-year-olds, with an average monthly premium of $401.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Shelter $401 $4,810
Nationwide $414 $4,973
Kentucky Farm Bureau $437 $5,248
Geico $645 $7,738
State Farm $657 $7,891

Cheapest Kentucky Car Insurance For 17-Year-Olds

Geico has the lowest-cost rates for 17-year-olds, with an average premium of $241.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Geico $241 $2,893
State Farm $275 $3,294
Kentucky Farm Bureau $294 $3,525
USAA $349 $4,183
Auto-Owners Insurance $386 $4,632

Cheapest Kentucky Car Insurance For 18-Year-Olds

Geico has the lowest rates for 18-year-olds, with an average monthly premium of $237.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Geico $237 $2,842
State Farm $324 $3,893
USAA $294 $3,522
Auto-Owners Insurance $310 $3,723
Travelers $349 $4,185

Cheapest Kentucky Car Insurance For 21-Year-Olds

GEICO has the cheapest rates for 21-year-olds, with an average monthly premium of $154.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Geico $154 $1,843
State Farm $175 $2,095
USAA $179 $2,143
Auto-Owners Insurance $202 $2,425
Travelers $216 $2,592
 

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Good Drivers

Good drivers, people with clean driving records, usually get lower insurance rates. Insurance companies determine risk based on someone’s history, and people without any violations or collisions are deemed lower risk. This advantageous risk profile is suited for people with a history of responsible and safe driving, suggesting a reduced risk of filing claims in the future.

Insurers, in turn, are more willing to afford lower premiums, reflecting the lessened financial risk they represent. For people who regularly follow traffic laws, avoid collisions, and demonstrate overall careful driving habits translates into savings on their auto insurance premiums over time.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Amica $118 $1,421
Travelers $125 $1,497
Cincinnati Insurance $133 $1,596
USAA $145 $1,735
Geico $154 $1,847

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Drivers With Prior Incidents

Drivers in Kentucky with a track record of prior incidents, including collisions, speeding infractions, or DUIs, usually face more challenges when seeking out affordable car insurance. These incidents make them high-risk in the eyes of insurers. This high-risk label is attributed to the higher odds of these people making claims in the future. As a result, insurers usually boost premiums for such motorists to offset the higher risk of financial payouts.

This is especially true in Kentucky, where the rate of traffic accidents can be higher than in some other states. The reasoning behind this pricing strategy is based on statistical analyses and risk assessment models, which show that a track record of driving incidents correlates with greater odds of future claims.

Cheapest car insurance in Kentucky for drivers with a speeding ticket

Kentucky Farm Bureau has average premiums of $94, making it the most affordable option for people with a speeding ticket.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Kentucky Farm Bureau $94 $1,128
Auto-Owners $162 $1,944
State Farm $175 $2,100
Travelers $203 $2,436
Geico $253 $3,036

Cheapest car insurance in Kentucky for drivers with an at-fault accident

Kentucky Farm Bureau has average rates of $92, making it the lowest-cost choice for people with an at-fault accident.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Kentucky Farm Bureau $92 $1,104
State Farm $178 $2,136
Travelers $218 $2,616
Auto-Owners $226 $2,712
Progressive $364 $4,368

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky For Drivers After A DUI

Kentucky Farm Bureau has average rates of $201, making it the lowest-cost option for drivers with DUIs on their records.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Kentucky Farm Bureau $201 $2,412
Travelers $228 $2,736
Progressive $307 $3,684
Auto-Owners $377 $4,524
Allstate $453 $5,436

Average Cost Of Car Insurance In Kentucky

Average Cost In Kentucky – By Age

Age Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
16 $318 $3,821
17 $305 $3,663
18 $286 $3,434
19 $272 $3,260
21 $237 $2,854
25 $188 $2,251
35 $101 $1,210
45 $85 $1,025
55 $79 $946
65 $103 $1,241
75 $113 $1,354

Average Cost In Kentucky – By Credit Tier

Credit Tier Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Excellent $103 $1,240
Good $128 $1,532
Fair $215 $2,583
Poor $245 $2,935

Cheapest Car Insurance In Kentucky By City:

City Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Owensboro $123 $1,481
Villa Hills $131 $1,575
Madisonville $132 $1,586
Erlanger $135 $1,617
Independence $141 $1,693
Newport $145 $1,743

Average Cost In Kentucky – By Gender & Marital Status

Gender Marital Status Average Annual Cost
Female Single $1,312
Male Single $1,358
Female Married $1,232
Male Married $1,267

Minimum Car Insurance Requirement In Kentucky

The minimum Kentucky car insurance coverage requirements under state law are as follows:

  • PIP: $10,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $10,000 per accident
  • Bodily injury liability: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident
  • Uninsured motorist coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident

In Kentucky, the law requires that all drivers must carry a minimum level of vehicle insurance to legally operate a vehicle. This requirement is based on the Financial Responsibility Law and the No-Fault Law, designed to ensure that motorists can foot the bill associated with vehicle accidents. Specifically, the law requires two primary kinds of coverage: Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Property Damage Liability (PDL).

Personal Injury Protection (PIP) is optional in Kentucky. Kentucky is a choice no-fault state. That means drivers can opt to reject PIP coverage if they want. This coverage means that if there’s an accident, each driver’s insurance will cover their medical expenses, regardless of who caused the collision. The minimum PIP coverage in Kentucky is $10,000. This coverage also extends to cover lost salary and death benefits, providing a financial safety net for the driver and their household members.

Property Damage Liability (PDL) is required coverage in Kentucky. This insurance pays for damages that the driver or members of their household cause to other’s property in a vehicle accident. Kentucky’s minimum required PDL coverage is $10,000. PDL does not cover the driver’s car damages; it’s only for the damages inflicted on other people’s property.

 

Car Insurance Discounts In Kentucky

While seeking vehicle insurance, it’s a good idea to examine the insurance providers that present the best discounts tailored to your situation. Additionally, talk to your insurance agent to learn about discounts that you might not be currently benefiting from.

Below is more insight into the common kinds of discounts offered by top vehicle insurance companies:

  • Multi-policy: Bundle multiple insurance policies with the same insurance provider.
  • Good student: This discount is for post-secondary and high school students under 25 who maintain a B or better academic average.
  • Multi-vehicle: Insuring more than one vehicle under a single policy or combining vehicle insurance policies earns you this price cut.
  • Homeowners: If you own a residence, you might qualify for this discount.
  • Good driver: You can save by maintaining a good driving record (with no at-fault collisions, DUI, or traffic tickets over the last three years).
  • Pay-in-full: Save on your auto insurance policy by paying in full up front.
  • Defensive driving: Those who enroll in a defensive driving program get a discount.
  • Paperless: Receive a price cut by getting our documents via email.
  • Military: This is applicable to veterans and active-duty military members.
  • Driver training: Get a price cut by taking a driver education training program.
  • New car: Drivers who buy new vehicles, usually no more than three model years old, qualify for a discount.
  • Senior: This often applies to customers who are 55 or older.
  • Safe car: If your car has safety features such as anti-theft technology, you can get a discount.

FAQs

How much is car insurance a month in Kentucky?

The monthly expense for car insurance in Kentucky varies but usually ranges from $175 to $330. Factors impacting the cost include your driving record, coverage type, and the make and model of your car.

What is the minimum car insurance one must have in Kentucky?

Remember that Kentucky is a choice no-fault state, which means you can choose whether or not to get Personal Injury Protection. Minimum PIP coverage is $10,000. In Kentucky, the minimum car insurance required for Property Damage Liability (PDL) is $10,000.

Which insurance is better in Kentucky?

The “best” insurance in Kentucky depends on what you’re looking for. But it’s hard to beat the likes of Kentucky Farm Bureau, specifically, and State Farm or Geico.

Go back to top