Cheapest Low-Income Car Insurance In Indiana 2024

My research indicates that State Farm offers the most affordable car insurance in Indiana for those with limited incomes.

min read -
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Getting affordable car insurance in Indiana is particularly tough for low-income residents. Indiana drivers, regardless of their income level, can find budget-friendly car insurance that keeps them legally on the road and in line with state regulations.

With 15 years of experience as an insurance agent and over three decades as a car insurance customer, I have firsthand knowledge of all the insurance providers I’ve dealt with, each catering to Indiana drivers in different ways.

Cheapest Low-Income Car Insurance In Indiana, 2024

Cheapest Low-Income Car Insurance, Indiana 2024

Compare Low-Income Car Insurance Companies In Indiana

Overall Rating Best Suited For A.M. Best Rating J.D. Power Rating Average Monthly Cost* Get A Quote





Instant Quote
State Farm

Cheapest Overall




Instant Quote

Poor Credit




Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Cheapest Low-Income Car Insurance Companies In Indiana

Cheapest Overall

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

10/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer reviews
9/10 Claim payouts
10/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

The car insurance sector in Indiana is fiercely competitive, with State Farm standing out as the most economical pick.

Following comprehensive research and a detailed review of Indiana car insurance costs, we found that State Farm offers competitive rates for full coverage, starting from just $94 per month.

It’s a great advantage for budget-conscious drivers looking for comprehensive coverage without spending excessively.

State Farm offers more than just budget-friendly rates; it consistently receives high rankings as one of the leading car insurance companies overall. Its reputation is built on a wide range of discounts and coverage options designed to meet various needs.

State Farm’s ability to offer affordability, flexibility, and thorough coverage gives it a strong advantage in Indiana’s car insurance industry, making it an appealing choice for drivers prioritizing value and quality.

It’s crucial to obtain affordable car insurance in Indiana. This ensures you can drive without the financial worry of potential damages or liabilities. With Indiana’s busy roads and high accident rates, cost-effective insurance is even more necessary.

It’s crucial to understand that affordable insurance doesn’t mean low quality. By comparing policies and making informed choices, you can find strong coverage that fits your budget and meets your needs without causing financial stress.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Cheapest rates for most drivers in Indiana
  • Numerous coverage options and discounts available
  • Superior AM Best financial strength rating
  • Must buy from a State Farm Agent

Cheapest Rates For Low-Income Car Insurance In Indiana

Insurance company Monthly Rate
State Farm $89
Farmers $94
GEICO $103
Progressive $115
Allstate $156

Best for Poor Credit

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer reviews
9/10 Claim payouts
8/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

GEICO emerges as the best and cheapest car insurance option in Indiana for drivers with poor credit. Numerous reports and studies have consistently shown GEICO to be the most affordable for those with less-than-perfect credit.

GEICO manages to be affordable without compromising on quality or service. With a reputation for comprehensive coverage and excellent customer service, GEICO offers strong protection to drivers regardless of their credit scores, making it a reliable choice for Indiana driver with poor credit.

GEICO also acknowledges that a low credit score doesn’t mean a driver is high-risk. Unlike some insurance companies that increase rates for poor credit, GEICO uses a more balanced method, considering factors like driving record and vehicle type.

This careful assessment allows GEICO to extend competitive rates to drivers with poor credit, making it a favored choice among many Indiana drivers.

Having a low income often goes hand in hand with a poor credit score, causing rates from some insurers to be double what they charge drivers with excellent credit.

Drivers with poor credit can keep premiums affordable by shopping for insurers that offer discounts and avoiding moving violations.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Best rates for most drivers in Indiana with poor credit
  • Variety of coverage options and discounts available
  • Strong AM Best financial strength rating
  • Available digital tools, though less robust than some competitors
  • Fewer GEICO agents in Indiana than many larger competitors

Cheapest Low-Income Car Insurance Rates For Poor Credit

Insurance company Monthly Rate
GEICO $152
State Farm $159
Erie $176
Allstate $256
Erie $294

Cheapest for Seniors

Overall Rating

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer reviews
8/10 Claim payouts
9/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

When it comes to car insurance for Indiana seniors, Nationwide stands out as the best and most budget-friendly option. This is supported by both industry research and customer testimonials.

For senior drivers, Nationwide provides highly competitive rates, establishing it as the best choice for budget-conscious seniors looking for strong coverage.

Car insurance rates often go up for older drivers, as insurance companies see them as more risky, much like they do with teenage drivers.

Slower response times, potential health issues that might impact driving, and a higher probability of serious injuries in crashes all add to this perceived risk.

According to research by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), fatal crash rates notably increase beginning at age 70, reaching their highest among drivers aged 85 and over.

Therefore, seniors could notice an increase in their premiums to balance the potential claim costs.

Many insurance companies thankfully provide discounts for senior drivers, helping to make comprehensive coverage more affordable.

Benefits & Drawbacks

  • Auto, homeowners, life, and other insurance products available
  • High financial strength ratings
  • Comprehensive mobile app for digital policy management
  • Can only buy from Nationwide agents
  • Not rated by J.D. Power for customer service

Cheapest Low-Income Car Insurance Rates In Indiana For Seniors

Insurance company Monthly Rate
Nationwide $27
State Farm $28
Erie $33
Allstate $57

By law, Indiana drivers need car insurance to handle accident costs. The minimum coverage mandates that each policy must include at least:

  • $25,000 in bodily injury per person: This amount is the most your insurer will pay for the medical expenses of a single person injured in an accident you cause.
  • $50,000 in bodily injury per accident: This is the total amount your insurer will cover for all medical expenses if multiple people are injured in an accident you cause.
  • $25,000 in property damage liability: This covers the cost of damage you cause to someone else’s property, such as their car, in an accident.

While these are the required minimums, you need to consider if this coverage is enough to protect you financially in case of an accident. If the expenses surpass your coverage limits, you might have to pay the difference. For this reason, many drivers choose higher coverage levels to be fully protected.

Full Coverage Options

While “full coverage” isn’t an official insurance term, it typically describes a combination of coverages that protect against a wide range of potential damages and losses. This generally encompasses liability coverage (for bodily injury and property damage), collision coverage, and comprehensive coverage.

When you cause injuries or property damage to others in an accident, liability coverage pays for those costs. Collision coverage covers the damage to your vehicle from hitting another car or object.

Comprehensive coverage handles incidents unrelated to collisions, like theft, vandalism, fire, or natural disasters. Full coverage insurance is essentially a complete package that offers peace of mind both on the road and off.

Does Indiana Have A Government-Sponsored Car Insurance Program For Low-Income Families?

While some states have government-sponsored car insurance programs for low-income families, Indiana does not. Nonetheless, car insurance is required for legal vehicle registration and operation in the state.

Does income affect car insurance rates in Indiana?

Contrary to what many might think, income doesn’t directly affect car insurance premiums in Indiana. Insurers typically evaluate several factors, such as age, location, driving history, vehicle type, and coverage levels, to calculate premiums.

How To Save On Car Insurance Costs In Indiana

The car insurance landscape in Indiana can be complex, but employing the right methods can lead to significant savings on your premiums. Here are three tried-and-true tips for Indiana drivers to lower their car insurance costs.

Compare Rates from Different Providers

Comparing rates from different providers is a key strategy for cutting car insurance expenses. These rates are influenced by factors such as age, driving history, location, and others.

Hence, insurance premiums may vary widely across different providers. So, take the time to request quotes from various insurers and opt for the one that provides the best coverage for your needs and is affordable.


Leverage Discounts

Many insurance providers offer different discounts that can decrease your premiums. These could include discounts for safe driving, bundling policies, being a good student, or having safety features in your vehicle. Speak to your insurer to learn about the discounts they provide and find out if you qualify for any.


Adjust Your Coverage and Deductibles

You can save on car insurance by modifying your coverage and deductibles. For older cars, it may make sense to drop collision and comprehensive coverages if their expenses exceed the car’s value.

Increasing your deductible is another way to lower your premium. Just be sure that the deductible amount is something you can afford if you ever need to file a claim.


Our Methodology

By examining various aspects such as customer service ratings, available insurance products, pricing details, and insights from online reviews and user feedback, I've constructed a thorough overview of car insurance providers. Leveraging my 15+ years of direct industry experience as a licensed agent, frequent interactions with representatives from diverse companies, and firsthand encounters buying insurance in Indiana, this perspective is thorough and well-crafted.


Quotes Analyzed


Brands Reviewed


Years of experience


Research Hours


How can low income families get affordable car insurance in Indiana?  

To get the best car insurance deal in Indiana, it’s important to compare quotes from different providers, ask about available discounts, and shop around.

What is the minimum amount of car insurance you have to carry in Indiana?  

In Indiana, it’s mandatory for all drivers to have a certain level of car insurance. This comprises $25,000 coverage per person for bodily injury, $50,000 for bodily injuries per accident, and $25,000 for property damage.

Go back to top