Cheapest Non-Owner Car Insurance In New York 2024

In New York, GEICO offers the most affordable non-owner car insurance, averaging $221 annually.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 10 December 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

When it comes to non-owner car insurance in New York, GEICO stands out as the most affordable option, with an average annual rate of $221. For drivers who don’t own a car but still need insurance, non-owner policies provide liability coverage when you’re behind the wheel of a borrowed or rented vehicle.

This type of insurance is a cost-effective solution for those who want to meet state requirements or maintain continuous coverage without owning a car.

Does New York Allow Non-Owner Car Insurance?

Yes, New York allows non-owner car insurance policies. These policies are specifically designed for individuals who do not own a vehicle but occasionally drive rented or borrowed cars. They provide liability coverage, ensuring drivers meet the state’s minimum insurance requirements, which include coverage for bodily injury and property damage.

Non-owner car insurance offers a practical and legal option for those needing liability protection without the commitment of owning a vehicle.

Cheapest Overall Non-Owner Car Insurance In New York

In New York, GEICO offers the most affordable non-owner car insurance, with an average annual rate of $221.

Company Cheapest Annual Rate Cheapest Monthly Rate
Geico $221 $18
Erie Insurance $298 $25
State Farm $431 $36
Progressive $691 $58
Travelers $907 $76

Cheapest Non-Owner Car Insurance With A Clean Driving Record

The cheapest non-owner car insurance company in New York for drivers with a clean record is Kemper, with an average rate of $442 per year.

Company Annual Rate Monthly Rate
Kemper $442 $37
Geico $718 $60
Progressive $770 $64
State Farm $1,184 $99
Travelers $1,598 $133

Cheapest Non-Owner SR-22 Car Insurance In New York

The cheapest non-owner SR-22 car insurance company in New York is Progressive, with an average annual rate of $913.

Company Annual Rate Monthly Rate
Progressive $913 $76
USAA $1,309 $109
State Farm $1,765 $147
Geico $1,850 $154
Allstate $2,100 $175

What Is Non-Owner Car Insurance?

Non-owner car insurance is a type of liability coverage designed for individuals who drive but do not own a car. It provides financial protection in the event that the driver causes an accident, covering bodily injury and property damage to others.

This type of auto insurance is ideal for those who frequently rent cars, borrow vehicles, or use car-sharing services. However, it does not cover damage to the vehicle being driven or personal injuries sustained by the driver.

Here’s a comparison table between non-owner car insurance and a full coverage policy:

Feature Non-Owner Car Insurance Full Coverage Policy
Purpose Liability protection for non-vehicle owners Comprehensive protection for vehicle owners
Covers Bodily injury and property damage to others Liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage
Excludes Damage to the vehicle driven, personal injuries Typically covers damage to your own vehicle and self
Cost Lower premiums Higher premiums due to extensive coverage
Ideal For Drivers without a personal vehicle Vehicle owners seeking comprehensive protection
Flexibility Generally not customizable Customizable options for broader protection

New York Minimum Auto Insurance Requirements

In New York, drivers must meet specific minimum auto insurance requirements to legally operate a vehicle. These include liability coverage of at least $25,000 for bodily injury per person and $50,000 per accident, as well as $10,000 for property damage per accident.

Additionally, New York requires $50,000 in personal injury protection (PIP) to cover medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of who caused the accident. Uninsured motorist coverage of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident is also mandatory. These requirements ensure financial responsibility and protection for all parties involved in an accident.

What Is SR-22 Insurance?

SR-22 is not a type of car insurance but rather a certificate of financial responsibility required for certain high-risk drivers. It serves as proof that the driver carries the minimum liability insurance required by state law.

Typically mandated after serious driving offenses like DUIs, reckless driving, or multiple traffic violations, the SR-22 is filed by the insurance company with the state’s motor vehicle department. While the SR-22 itself isn’t insurance, obtaining one often results in higher premiums because it signifies the driver is considered a greater risk by insurers. This requirement usually lasts for a specified period, such as three years.

Average Cost Of Non-Owner Car Insurance In New York

Understanding the average cost of non-owner car insurance in New York is essential for anyone who frequently rents or borrows cars. This type of insurance provides vital liability coverage without the full expenses of a standard policy, making it a practical choice for those without a personal vehicle.

Below is a comparison of average annual and monthly costs from different auto insurance providers, designed to help you make an informed decision:

Provider Annual Rate Monthly Rate
Nationwide $450 $38
American Family $610 $51
Liberty Mutual $670 $56
Farmers $735 $61
Allstate $790 $66

Average Cost Of Non-Owner Car Insurance In New York – By Age

Age plays a significant role in determining the average cost of non-owner car insurance in New York. Insurance companies assess risk based on various factors, and age is one of the most influential. Younger drivers often face higher premiums due to their perceived inexperience and higher risk of accidents.

Conversely, older drivers may enjoy lower rates as they are generally considered more experienced and lower risk. For example, a 20-year-old might pay around $900 annually, while a 50-year-old could see rates closer to $500.

Below is a table illustrating how average non-owner car insurance rates vary by age:

Age Annual Rate
18 $1,100
20 $900
25 $750
30 $700
35 $650
40 $620
45 $580
50 $500
55 $490
60 $480

Average Cost Of Non Owner Car Insurance In New York Cities

Location is a critical factor influencing the average cost of car insurance in New York. Insurance providers consider various elements such as traffic density, crime rates, and local regulations when determining rates for different areas. Urban centers like New York City tend to have higher premiums due to the elevated risk factors associated with dense traffic and higher crime rates. In contrast, smaller towns usually offer more affordable rates.

Here is a table showcasing the average non-owner car insurance rates for five different cities in New York:

City Annual Rate
New York City $950
Buffalo $720
Rochester $700
Syracuse $680
Albany $650

Average Rates Vs Traditional Car Insurance

Understanding the distinction between non-owner car insurance and traditional car insurance is essential for making informed financial decisions. Non-owner car insurance is designed for individuals who frequently drive but do not own a vehicle. It primarily covers liability, offering protection against bodily injury and property damage to others, which generally makes it more affordable than traditional car insurance.

On the other hand, traditional car insurance includes comprehensive and collision coverage, protecting the vehicle itself from damage, theft, and more, thus resulting in higher premiums.

Here is a comparison table of average rates for non-owner versus traditional car insurance across five companies:

Company Non-Owner Annual Rate Traditional Annual Rate
Progressive $500 $1,200
USAA $530 $1,350
State Farm $550 $1,400
Geico $570 $1,450
Allstate $600 $1,500

Should You Get Non-Owner Car Insurance?

Non-owner car insurance is a valuable option for individuals who don’t own a vehicle but still find themselves in situations where liability coverage is necessary. Below are the different types of people who should consider this insurance, broken down by their specific needs.

Renters

If you frequently rent cars, non-owner car insurance can save you money and provide better coverage than the insurance offered by rental companies. With a non-owner policy, you’ll have consistent liability coverage, which can be more comprehensive and cost-effective over time.

Car Borrowers

People who borrow cars from friends or family members occasionally may benefit from non-owner car insurance. It ensures you’re covered for liability if you’re at fault in an accident while driving someone else’s vehicle, without relying solely on the car owner’s insurance policy.

License Reinstatement

Non-owner car insurance is often required for drivers reinstating their license after a suspension or revocation due to serious violations, such as a DUI. Filing an SR-22 alongside a non-owner policy demonstrates financial responsibility and compliance with state requirements.

Infrequent Drivers

If you rarely drive but still want to maintain continuous insurance coverage to avoid gaps, a non-owner policy is a practical solution. It helps you avoid higher premiums in the future, as gaps in coverage can signal a higher risk to insurers.

Drivers Between Cars

If you’ve sold your car or are in between purchasing vehicles, non-owner car insurance can provide interim liability protection. This ensures you remain insured during the transition and maintain a good insurance history.

How To Get Non-Owner Car Insurance In New York

Securing a non-owner car insurance policy in New York is a straightforward process. Follow these step-by-step instructions to find and purchase the right policy for your needs.

Assess Your Insurance Needs

Determine why you need non-owner car insurance. Are you looking to meet state requirements, reinstate a license, or ensure liability coverage when driving borrowed or rented cars? Understanding your specific needs will help you choose the right policy.

1

Gather Personal Information

Prepare the necessary details, including your driver’s license number, driving history, and any required documentation like an SR-22 if applicable. Insurers will ask for this information to assess your risk profile.

2

Research Providers

Look for insurance companies that offer non-owner car insurance in New York. Compare rates, customer reviews, and coverage options to narrow down your choices. Companies like GEICO, State Farm, and Progressive often provide competitive rates.

3

Get Quotes

Request quotes from multiple insurers. Be honest about your driving habits and the purpose of the policy to ensure accurate pricing. Compare the premiums, coverage limits, and deductibles for each policy.

4

Choose A Policy

Select the policy that best meets your needs and budget. Make sure it includes liability coverage that complies with New York’s minimum requirements, as well as any additional features you may want.

5

Apply For The Policy

Submit your application online, over the phone, or in person with the chosen insurer. Provide all requested documents and information during the application process.

6

Review The Terms

Before finalizing your purchase, carefully review the policy terms and conditions. Ensure you understand the coverage limits, exclusions, and any additional fees.

7

Pay The Premium

Pay your premium to activate the policy. Many insurers offer flexible payment plans, including monthly or annual options, to suit your financial situation.

8

Maintain Your Policy

Keep your policy active by making timely payments. If you need an SR-22 filing, confirm that the insurer has submitted it to the state on your behalf.

9

Average Non-Owner Car Insurance Rates vs Other US States

State Annual Rate
Alabama $450
Alaska $480
Arizona $500
Arkansas $460
California $600
Colorado $520
Connecticut $550
Florida $650
Georgia $500
Illinois $470
Indiana $440
Kentucky $480
Louisiana $630
Michigan $680
New Mexico $490
North Carolina $430
Ohio $420
Pennsylvania $540
Texas $530
Washington $510

Our Methodology

Our methodology for evaluating car insurance companies involves a thorough analysis of multiple factors. We compare average premiums across various profiles and coverage scenarios to assess affordability. Customer satisfaction ratings are gathered from surveys, reviews, and feedback across trusted platforms. To ensure reliability, we evaluate financial strength using ratings from reputable agencies.

We also analyze coverage options, flexibility, and inclusiveness. Additionally, we review discounts and extra benefits offered by each insurer. To provide a well-rounded evaluation, we incorporate insights and data from other reputable insurance review sites, ensuring accurate and comprehensive recommendations for non-owner car insurance.

109

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

52

Brands Reviewed

30+

Research Hours

FAQs

Does New York require non-owner insurance?

No, New York does not require non-owner car insurance. However, it is an option for drivers who need liability coverage but do not own a vehicle, such as those reinstating a license or driving borrowed cars.

How do you insure a car you don’t own?

To insure a car you don’t own, you can purchase a non-owner car insurance policy. This provides liability coverage for driving rented or borrowed vehicles and can meet state insurance requirements if necessary.

Go back to top