Cheapest Non-Owner Car Insurance In Ohio 2024

The most cost-effective non-owner car insurance in Ohio is provided by Auto-Owners, costing $238 annually on average.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 10 December 2024
Written by Doug Schaffer
On this page Open

Drivers in Ohio can save with Auto-Owners’ non-owner car insurance, which costs $238 a year on average. It’s a great way to get liability coverage if you drive rented or borrowed cars without owning one.

Does Ohio Allow Non-Owner Car Insurance?

Non-owner car insurance is permitted in Ohio and is tailored for drivers without cars. It provides liability coverage to satisfy the state’s legal requirements for property damage and bodily injury.

Cheapest Overall Non-Owner Car Insurance In Ohio

With an average yearly rate of $238, Auto-Owners has the most affordable non-owner car insurance in Ohio.

Company Cheapest Annual Rate Cheapest Monthly Rate
State Farm $2,158 $180
Auto-Owners $238 $20
Progressive $292 $25
Nationwide $468 $39
Travelers $382 $32

Cheapest Non-Owner Car Insurance With A Clean Driving Record

With an annual average rate of $238, Auto-Owners is the most affordable option for non-owner car insurance in Ohio for those with a clean driving history.

Company Annual Rate Monthly Rate
State Farm $2,158 $180
Auto-Owners $238 $20
Progressive $292 $25
Nationwide $468 $39
Travelers $382 $32

Cheapest Non-Owner SR-22 Car Insurance In Ohio

For non-owner SR-22 insurance in Ohio, Auto-Owners is the least expensive provider, with an average annual rate of $292.

Company Annual Rate Monthly Rate
Farmers $1,057 $88
State Farm $2,398 $200
Progressive $495 $42
Auto-Owners $292 $25
Nationwide $598 $50

What Is Non-Owner Car Insurance?

Non-owner car insurance is a type of policy that covers drivers without a personal vehicle. It includes liability protection, paying for injuries or damages caused to others during an accident. Perfect for those who rent or borrow cars, this policy excludes coverage for the driver’s injuries or repairs to the vehicle being driven.

Feature Non-Owner Car Insurance Full Coverage Policy
Purpose Liability protection for non-vehicle owners Comprehensive protection for vehicle owners
Covers Bodily injury and property damage to others Liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage
Excludes Damage to the vehicle driven, personal injuries Typically covers damage to your own vehicle and self
Cost Lower premiums Higher premiums due to extensive coverage
Ideal For Drivers without a personal vehicle Vehicle owners seeking comprehensive protection
Flexibility Generally not customizable Customizable options for broader protection

Minimum Car Insurance Requirements in Ohio

To legally drive in Ohio, drivers are required to have insurance that meets specific minimums. These include $25,000 for bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage. Personal injury protection (PIP) is not mandatory, and uninsured motorist coverage of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident is also necessary.

What Is SR-22 Insurance?

SR-22 is not a form of car insurance but a certificate proving financial responsibility for high-risk drivers. It shows that the driver has the minimum required liability coverage as per state law. Typically mandated after serious violations like DUIs or reckless driving, the SR-22 is filed with the state’s department of motor vehicles by the insurance provider.

Even though it’s not insurance, drivers with an SR-22 often face higher premiums due to being considered higher-risk. The SR-22 requirement usually lasts for a specified period, often three years.

Average Cost Of Non-Owner Car Insurance In Ohio

If you frequently rent or borrow cars in Ohio, it’s important to know the average cost of non-owner car insurance. This coverage gives you essential liability protection without the higher costs of a full car insurance policy, making it a practical option.

Below, we’ve provided a comparison of average annual and monthly premiums from different insurance companies to assist you in making an informed choice.

Provider Annual Rate Monthly Rate
Geico $513 $43
Nationwide $652 $55
Farmers $750 $63
Allied $598 $50
Progressive $358 $30

Average Cost Of Non-Owner Car Insurance In Ohio – By Age

In Ohio, the average cost of non-owner car insurance is heavily influenced by the driver’s age. Younger drivers usually face higher premiums due to their perceived lack of experience and higher accident risk. Older drivers, however, tend to enjoy lower rates as they are seen as safer drivers. For example, a 20-year-old might pay approximately $900 annually, while a 50-year-old might pay about $500. Below is a table showing how rates vary by age group.

Age Annual Rate
16 $711
17 $689
18 $595
19 $435
20 $384
21 $329
22 $302
23 $282
24 $266
25 $236
30 $219
35 $216
40 $212
45 $210
50 $204
55 $199
60 $200
65 $214
70 $230
75 $259

Average Cost Of Non Owner Car Insurance In Ohio Cities

Your location in Ohio can greatly influence the cost of non-owner car insurance. Insurance companies consider several factors, including traffic volume, crime rates, and local regulations when setting premiums. Urban areas like Cincinnati tend to have higher rates due to the higher risks associated with crowded streets and crime. Conversely, smaller towns often offer lower premiums.

Below, you’ll find a table showing average non-owner car insurance rates across five Ohio cities.

City Annual Rate
Lorain $234
Parma $235
Canton $232
Cincinnati $265
Toledo $260

Average Rates Vs Traditional Car Insurance

To make informed financial decisions, it’s important to understand the difference between non-owner car insurance and traditional car insurance. Non-owner car insurance is for individuals who drive but don’t own a vehicle. It covers liability for bodily injury and property damage to others, which tends to be more affordable than traditional car insurance.

Traditional car insurance, on the other hand, includes coverage for the vehicle itself, such as comprehensive and collision coverage, leading to higher premiums. Below is a comparison table of average rates for both types of insurance across five companies.

Company Non-Owner Annual Rate Traditional Annual Rate
Progressive $500 $1,200
USAA $530 $1,350
State Farm $550 $1,400
Geico $570 $1,450
Allstate $600 $1,500

Should You Get Non-Owner Car Insurance In Ohio?

Non-owner car insurance is a great option for individuals who don’t own a car but need liability coverage. Here’s who should consider this type of insurance based on their specific needs:

  • Renters: For those who often rent vehicles, non-owner insurance can provide better coverage than what’s offered by rental companies. It ensures continuous liability protection, which may be more cost-effective over time.
  • Car Borrowers: If you occasionally borrow cars from others, non-owner car insurance provides liability coverage if you’re at fault in an accident, ensuring you’re protected without relying on the vehicle owner’s policy.
  • License Reinstatement: If you need to reinstate your license after a serious violation like a DUI, non-owner insurance is often required. Pairing it with an SR-22 filing shows you’re complying with state laws for financial responsibility.
  • Infrequent Drivers: Non-owner car insurance is perfect for drivers who don’t drive often but want to avoid the risk of gaps in their coverage. It helps prevent premium increases by maintaining continuous insurance.
  • Drivers Between Cars: If you’ve sold your car or are in the process of buying a new one, non-owner insurance ensures you’re still covered during the transition. It helps maintain insurance continuity and a good record.

How To Get Non-Owner Car Insurance In Ohio

If you don’t own a car but still need insurance in Ohio, here’s how to secure non-owner coverage.

Identify Your Needs

Consider why you need this coverage. Whether for legal requirements or to cover liability when driving rented or borrowed cars, knowing your need helps you find the right policy.

1

Collect Your Info

Gather your driver’s license number, driving history, and any necessary paperwork (like an SR-22 if needed).

2

Explore Providers

Research companies offering non-owner car insurance in Ohio. Compare options, customer reviews, and pricing to find a good match.

3

Request Quotes

Obtain quotes from multiple insurers. Be upfront about your driving habits and needs to get an accurate quote. Compare the policies and premiums to make an informed choice.

4

Select Your Policy

Pick the policy that suits your needs and budget, ensuring it includes the required liability coverage for Ohio.

5

Apply for Insurance

Submit your application online, by phone, or in person, providing all required documents.

6

Review the Terms

Before finalizing your decision, carefully review the terms, coverage, and exclusions to ensure the policy fits your needs.

7

Pay Your Premium

Pay your premium to activate the policy. Many providers offer different payment plans to make it easier.

8

Maintain the Policy

Stay on top of payments to keep your policy active. If needed, confirm that your SR-22 filing is completed with the state.

9

Average Non-Owner Car Insurance Rates vs Other US States

State Annual Rate
Alabama $450
Alaska $480
Arizona $500
Arkansas $460
California $600
Colorado $520
Connecticut $550
Florida $650
Georgia $500
Illinois $470
Indiana $440
Kentucky $480
Louisiana $630
Michigan $680
New Mexico $490
North Carolina $430
Oregon $420
Pennsylvania $540
Texas $530
Washington $510

Our Methodology

Our process for assessing car insurance providers is based on a detailed analysis of several factors. We compare premiums across different coverage levels and driver profiles to determine cost-effectiveness. Customer satisfaction is gathered from surveys and reviews on trusted platforms. We also evaluate the financial stability of each company using ratings from reputable agencies. Our review looks at coverage options, flexibility, and additional perks insurers offer. We ensure our recommendations are well-rounded by including insights from other reliable insurance review sites.

47

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

16

Brands Reviewed

40+

Research Hours

FAQs

Does Ohio require non-owner insurance?

Non-owner car insurance is not compulsory in Ohio. Still, it’s a helpful option for individuals who need liability coverage, such as people who are reinstating their license or occasionally borrowing cars.

How do you insure a car you don’t own?

To insure a car you’re driving but don’t own, you can get non-owner car insurance. It covers liability for rented or borrowed vehicles and can also help fulfill state insurance obligations.

Go back to top