Best Health Insurance Companies In North Carolina

min read -
Updated: 15 December 2025
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

With 15 years of experience in health insurance and 12 years in North Carolina, I’ve found Aetna to be one of the best options for comprehensive and affordable healthcare coverage.

The average monthly premium for an Aetna Silver plan in North Carolina is about $498, though costs depend on factors like location and age. A 40-year-old may pay around $573 per month.

Aetna’s broad provider network and perks, such as CVS Health discounts, add value. Their lower-than-average complaint rate reflects their dedication to customer satisfaction.

Best Health Insurance Companies In North Carolina 2026

aetna
Best Overall - Aetna
blue cross
Best PPO/HMO Plans - Blue Cross / Blue Shield

Compare The Best Health Insurance Companies In North Carolina

Overall Rating Best Suited For J.D. Power Rating AM Best Rating Online Buying Experience
Aetna
4

Best Overall

616

A (Excellent)

9.7/10

Blue Cross/Blue Shield
3

Best PPO/HMO Plans

593

A (Excellent)

9.5/10

Humana
3

Best Provider Network

582

A- (Excellent)

9.6/10

Cigna
4

Best Policyholder Service

581

A (Excellent)

9.7/10

MetLife
3

Best Add-On Coverages

N/A

A+ (Superior)

9.5/10

Scroll to see comparisons

Best Health Insurance Companies in North Carolina 2026


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

In North Carolina, Aetna stands out as the best health insurance provider due to its affordability, extensive network, and well-rounded coverage options. It’s a great fit for individuals, families, and employers.

With plan options like HMOs, PPOs, and EPOs, Aetna ensures flexibility. It also provides wellness programs and virtual healthcare for added accessibility.

The CVS Health partnership further enhances Aetna’s value by offering savings on prescriptions and wellness programs while maintaining affordable premiums.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Lower-priced premiums compared to other insurance agencies.
  • A substantial network of professionals located in North Carolina.
  • CVS offers discounts on your prescriptions through its partnerships.
Drawbacks
  • You might have to obtain a referral for specialist visits depending on your plan.
  • Not many temporary health insurance offerings.
  • When it's a peak period, customer service wait times might be longer than usual.

Best PPO-HMO Plans

Overall Rating
3

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For North Carolinians looking for flexible health insurance, Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) of North Carolina provides strong PPO and HMO options with excellent in-network benefits. Their large network spans the state and extends nationwide, offering convenience and accessibility.

BCBS North Carolina plans come with various deductible and co-pay options, as well as extras like telemedicine, wellness incentives, and chronic disease support. PPO plans provide more flexibility in choosing providers, while HMOs help manage costs effectively.

With the BlueCard® program, BCBS members can access healthcare in multiple states, making it a great choice for frequent travelers or those needing nationwide provider access.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Get countrywide access with the BlueCard® program.
  • Various adaptable choices for PPO and HMO plans.
  • Distinguished for their skillful management of claims and focus on customer service.
Drawbacks
  • More substantial premiums than those from certain other companies.
  • A handful of entry-level plans offer a more limited network of doctors and clinics.
  • Using healthcare providers who aren't in your network can incur extra costs.

Best Provider Network

Overall Rating
3

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For North Carolinians looking for a large provider network, Humana is a standout health insurance option. Their plans cover hospitals, specialists, and primary care doctors, ensuring comprehensive in-network care.

Humana’s Medicare Advantage plans are among the best in the state, making them an excellent choice for seniors. Their employer-sponsored plans also feature wellness programs and preventive health services. Their Value-Based Care model prioritizes prevention, helping members reduce medical expenses.

While their individual plan selection is smaller, their group and Medicare options are among North Carolina’s top-rated choices for seniors and employees.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • An expansive network of providers helps alleviate issues with out-of-network services.
  • Affordable Medicare Advantage plans worth exploring.
  • Reliable preventive care and wellness programs.
Drawbacks
  • There is a shortage of individual health plans on the market.
  • Certain policies exhibit premiums that are higher than the usual average.
  • There can be a noticeable delay in how fast customer service responds.

Best Policyholder Service

Overall Rating
4

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For North Carolinians who want a health insurer with top-tier customer service and seamless claims handling, Cigna is an excellent choice. Their online platform is easy to navigate, and their support team is always ready to assist.

Cigna’s plans provide comprehensive coverage, including emergency care worldwide, making them ideal for frequent travelers. They also offer strong mental health benefits, supporting members with behavioral health needs.

With reliable claims processing and outstanding service, Cigna ranks among North Carolina’s best insurers.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Reliable customer support and claims service.
  • Good mental condition and the perks of digital health services.
  • Coverage available worldwide for constant travelers.
Drawbacks
  • You may encounter higher out-of-pocket charges with some health plans.
  • PPO health insurance can be financially challenging for individuals.
  • Options for plans are more limited for those who are self-employed.

Best Add-On Coverages

Overall Rating
3

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
7/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claims
7/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For individuals looking for additional health coverage, MetLife provides supplemental insurance options like dental, vision, disability, and more. Though not a primary health insurance provider, their plans offer valuable benefits.

These add-ons help individuals and families minimize out-of-pocket medical expenses and provide financial stability. MetLife’s coverage is ideal for those needing extra protection.

If you already have health insurance but want to expand your benefits, MetLife’s add-ons offer great options.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Best for added coverage support.
  • Established a reputation for financial resilience.
  • Smart pricing for optional coverage add-ons.
Drawbacks
  • A lack of options for basic health care plans.
  • Less well-rounded than full-service offerings
  • There may be a waiting phase for particular add-ons before their benefits start.

Common Health Insurance Terms

Learning about health insurance can be difficult due to confusing terminology. Here are key terms North Carolinians might hear.

Premium – The monthly amount paid to maintain health coverage.
Deductible – The money you must spend before insurance starts helping.
Copay – A fixed cost for medical visits or prescriptions.
Coinsurance – A shared expense between you and the insurance company.
Out-of-Pocket Maximum – The highest amount you’ll pay annually before insurance covers all costs.
HMO – A cost-effective plan with provider restrictions.
PPO – A plan that offers flexibility at a higher price.

Knowing these words can help you evaluate and select the best insurance policy for your needs.

Factors Affecting Health Insurance Costs In North Carolina

  • Age: Older individuals often pay more due to higher medical needs.
  • Location: Living in a big city means higher premiums, while rural areas may lack provider options.
  • Coverage Level: More comprehensive plans, such as Gold or Platinum, cost more.
  • Family Size: Adding dependents increases the total premium.
  • Tobacco Use: Insurance companies charge smokers extra.
  • Insurance Provider: Costs depend on the insurer’s pricing structure.

How To Save On Health Insurance In North Carolina

North Carolinians can decrease their health insurance costs by choosing affordable plans, using financial assistance programs, and making smart healthcare decisions. Here are some effective money-saving tips.

  • Pick an HDHP for Lower Premiums: These plans can be paired with an HSA for tax-free savings.
  • Compare Multiple Plans: Reviewing all options helps you find the right balance of cost and benefits.
  • See if You Qualify for ACA Subsidies: Based on income, you might get financial help.
  • Use Employer Health Plans: If offered, job-based insurance is usually the cheapest option.
  • Stay Within Your Insurance Network: Visiting in-network providers helps avoid extra costs.
  • Take Advantage of Preventive Care: Many services, like checkups and vaccines, are free.
  • Choose Generic Prescriptions: They are more affordable than brand-name drugs.

Exploring all coverage options ensures North Carolinians get top-quality health insurance at the best possible price.

How To Sign Up For A Health Insurance Policy

Signing up for health coverage in North Carolina is simple, but planning and meeting deadlines are important.

  • Determine Your Eligibility – Find out if you qualify for employer health plans, Medicare, Medicaid, or ACA plans.
  • Go to the Insurance Marketplace – Create an account on the official website.
  • Review Your Options – Compare coverage, costs, and doctor networks.
  • See If You Can Get Help – If eligible, financial aid will reduce your premium.
  • Pick a Plan – Select one that fits your healthcare needs.
  • Enroll in Coverage – Submit documents and finalize your plan.
  • Make the First Payment – Your insurance starts once you pay your premium.

Individuals facing significant life changes, such as losing a job or getting married, may be able to enroll in health insurance outside the open enrollment period.

Cheapest Health Insurance Companies In North Carolina

Affordable health insurance in North Carolina is within reach if you compare providers. Here are five companies that offer some of the lowest average premiums for Silver plans.

Insurance Company Average Monthly Premium (Silver Plan)
Blue Cross Blue Shield $390
MetLife $440
Humana $438
Aetna $473
Cigna $484

Please Note: These rates are estimates for a 40-year-old and may change based on age, residence, and financial aid eligibility.

If you’re searching for lower premiums, you may qualify for ACA subsidies. Many North Carolinians can significantly reduce their costs through assistance programs.

How Much Does Health Insurance Cost In North Carolina?

Health insurance prices in North Carolina change depending on factors like age, plan tier, and location. In 2025, the typical Silver plan costs $498 per month, Bronze plans average $372, and Gold plans cost $515. Catastrophic plans, tailored for younger and healthier people, cost around $375.

A 40-year-old’s Silver plan premium averages $573 per month. Subsidies, employer-sponsored plans, and marketplace options can help lower costs. Many North Carolinians qualify for ACA financial assistance.

Average Cost By Coverage Level

The cost of a health insurance plan in North Carolina varies based on coverage level. Plans are divided into four tiers—Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum—each offering different trade-offs between premiums and out-of-pocket costs.

Bronze plans offer lower monthly premiums but come with higher deductibles, while Platinum plans have higher monthly costs but lower out-of-pocket expenses. Below is a breakdown of the average monthly premiums for each tier.

Coverage Level Average Monthly Premium
Bronze $372
Silver $498
Gold $515
Platinum $600

Average Cost By Family Size

The price of health insurance in North Carolina depends on whether you’re getting an individual or family plan. Individual plans have lower premiums, while family plans—covering spouses and children—cost more as additional members are included. Below is a summary of average monthly premiums based on family size.

Family Size Average Monthly Premium
Individual (Single Adult) $573
Couple (Two Adults) $1,146
Family of Three $1,430
Family of Four $1,715
Family of Five $2,000

Average Cost Of Health Insurance Plans By City

Health insurance premiums in North Carolina depend on where you live, with factors like provider fees, insurer competition, and area health risks shaping costs. Below is a comparison of Silver plan rates in five major North Carolina cities.

City Average Monthly Premium (Silver Plan)

Raleigh

$448

Charlotte

$438

Winston-Salem

$422

Durham

$488

Greensboro

$452

Health Insurance Coverage Levels

Health insurance is categorized into four tiers, each with its own costs and benefits. North Carolinians should understand these options to make the best choice.

Bronze – Lowest monthly payments, but you’ll pay more for medical services. Good for healthy individuals.
Silver – Balanced cost and coverage, great for those who qualify for financial help.
Gold – Higher premiums, but you save on doctor visits and prescriptions.
Platinum – Highest monthly cost, but minimal out-of-pocket expenses.

The best plan choice varies depending on your healthcare usage, monthly budget, and willingness to take financial risks.

Health Insurance Options In North Carolina If You Have A Low Income

Several programs are in place to help North Carolinians access affordable healthcare and minimize out-of-pocket expenses.

Medicaid – Offers free or low-cost medical insurance to eligible low-income people.
CHIP – Provides health coverage for kids in families who don’t meet Medicaid’s requirements.
ACA Subsidies – Financial aid to make insurance more affordable.
FQHCs – Medical centers that charge fees based on income.
Charity Care – Some hospitals help uninsured patients by reducing or waiving medical costs.
Short-Term Insurance – Limited coverage for people in transition.

Exploring these resources allows people to access medical care without overwhelming expenses.

Our Methodology

How We Evaluate Health Insurance Companies in North Carolina

We assess health insurers using key factors to ensure fair and thorough reviews.

• Affordability – We compare premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket costs across plans.

• Customer Satisfaction – We review feedback, complaints, and how well insurers serve their members.

• Claims Processing – We examine how quickly and efficiently claims and reimbursements are handled.

• Coverage Options – We check for essential benefits, provider networks, and flexibility.

• Financial Stability – We assess insurers' ability to pay claims and stay financially strong.

• Extra Benefits – We consider digital tools, perks, and telehealth services.

75

Quotes Analyzed

15+

Years Of Industry Experience

25

Brands Reviewed

35+

Research Hours

Sources

About Bob Phillips

Having spent over fifteen years helping people plan their lives financially, Bob mastered many different financial products to help people achieve their financial goals, including life insurance, disability insurance, mutual funds, and stocks and bonds.
Read Full Bio
Go back to top