Best Cheap Homeowners Insurance in Madison, WI 2025
Erie offers the cheapest homeowners insurance to homeowners in Madison, with an average annual quote of $977.
We’ve saved shoppers an average of $450 per year on their home insurance.
In Madison, Erie provides the cheapest policy, with average annual rates of $977. However, keep in mind that the best insurer for you may vary based on your unique circumstances and requirements.
Madison experiences over 6,500 residential burglaries annually. Additionally, Madison’s rates climb with flooding, winter storms, and rising rebuild costs.
To help people navigate the tough home insurance market, I researched several options to find you the best and cheapest home insurance companies in Madison, WI.
Key Takeaways
Erie provides the cheapest home insurance policy in Madison, at an average annual rate of $977.
The average cost of homeowners insurance in Madison is $1,223 per year.
There are various ways to save on your premiums, such as shopping around for quotes and reassessing your coverage needs.
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance in Madison – Erie
Erie is the cheapest overall carrier for homeowners insurance in Madison, WI, with an average annual rate of $977.
| Company | Annual Premium |
| American Family | $1,070 |
| Erie | $977 |
| Allstate | $1,136 |
| Chubb | $1,041 |
| West Bend Mutual | $1,085 |
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance In Madison If You Have Poor Credit – Allstate
If your credit score is poor, Allstate provides the most affordable solution, with an average annual rate of $1,595.
| Insurance Company | Average Annual Premium |
| Nationwide | $1,990 |
| State Farm | $2,549 |
| Allstate | $1,595 |
| American Family | $2,420 |
| Rockford Mutual | $1,684 |
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance In Madison For Older Homes – Rural Mutual
For those with older homes, Rural Mutual offers the cheapest rates, averaging $905 per year.
Older homes often come with unique risks and maintenance issues, which can drive up insurance costs.
| Insurance Company | Average Annual Premium |
| State Farm | $1,480 |
| Farmers | $1,610 |
| Allstate | $1,042 |
| Rural Mutual | $905 |
| West Bend Mutual | $1,073 |
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance for Newly Constructed Homes – Allstate
If you’re the proud owner of a newly constructed home, Allstate offers the most cost-effective solution, with an average annual rate of $695.
| Insurance Company | Average Annual Premium |
| American Family | $784 |
| Chubb | $810 |
| State Farm | $758 |
| Allstate | $695 |
| Erie | $722 |
Cheapest Home Insurance In Madison for a History of Claims – Wisconsin Mutual
For homeowners with a history of claims, Wisconsin Mutual provides an affordable solution, with an average annual rate of $1,156.
A history of claims can raise red flags for insurers, often leading to higher premiums.
| Insurance Company | Average Annual Premium |
| Badger Mutual | $1,174 |
| Rural Mutual | $1,190 |
| Allstate | $1,947 |
| Wisconsin Mutual | $1,156 |
| State Farm | $1,691 |
Find Home Insurance in Madison
Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Madison, WI
To make your decision-making process easier, we’ve compiled a list of the top homeowners insurance companies in Madison, WI. These companies have been assessed based on their annual premiums, coverage options, customer satisfaction ratings, and overall reliability.
Take a look at our comparison chart below and find the perfect fit for your home insurance needs.
| Company | Annual Premium |
| American Family | $1,000 |
| Erie | $1,050 |
| Chubb | $1,022 |
| State Farm | $1,564 |
| West Bend Mutual | $1,166 |
| Amica | $1,430 |
| Auto-Owners | $1,332 |
How Much Is Homeowners Insurance In Madison, WI?
The average cost of home insurance in Madison is approximately $1,223 per year. It’s important to understand that rates are not a one-size-fits-all matter. They can fluctuate significantly based on a myriad of factors.
As you can see below, rates in Madison are lower than the National average as well as the Wisconsin State average.
| Area | Average Annual Premium |
| National | $2,408 |
| Wisconsin | $1,267 |
| Madison | $1,223 |
Average Madison Home Insurance Rates By ZIP Code
The cost of homeowners insurance in Madison, WI, can vary significantly based on the ZIP code.
The table below showcases average rates for different zip codes in Madison.
| ZIP Code | Average Annual Premium |
| 53711 | $1,015 |
| 53719 | $1,011 |
| 53717 | $1,025 |
| 53705 | $1,034 |
| 53703 | $1,020 |
Cheapest ZIP Codes For Home Insurance In Madison
At $994 per year, the ZIP code 53716 is the cheapest average ZIP code for home insurance in Madison.
| ZIP Code | Average Annual Premium |
| 53718 | $1,003 |
| 53716 | $994 |
| 53719 | $1,011 |
| 53714 | $1,000 |
| 53704 | $996 |
Most Expensive ZIP Codes For Home Insurance In Madison
The most expensive ZIP code in Madison is 53792, at an average annual premium of $1,048.
| ZIP Code | Average Annual Premium |
| 53706 | $1,042 |
| 53726 | $1,045 |
| 53715 | $1,030 |
| 53792 | $1,048 |
| 53705 | $1,035 |
Average Home Insurance Rates In Madison, WI By Deductible Amount
The deductible amount chosen for a homeowners insurance policy significantly affects the premium rates in Madison, WI. Generally, a higher deductible means lower premiums, but you’ll pay more out of pocket if you need to make a claim.
Here’s how the average home insurance rates in Madison fluctuate with insurers for different deductible amounts:
| Insurer | Annual Rate for $500 Deductible | Annual Rate for $1,000 Deductible | Annual Rate for $1,500 Deductible |
| American Family | $1,120 | $1,077 | $1,025 |
| West Bend Mutual | $1,133 | $1,085 | $1,040 |
| Allstate | $1,180 | $1,136 | $1,091 |
| State Farm | $1,620 | $1,550 | $1,495 |
| Erie | $1,022 | $975 | $930 |
Average Home Insurance Rates In Madison, WI By Coverage Amount
One of the key components that influences your premium is the dwelling coverage amount. This is the maximum amount your insurance company will pay to rebuild or repair your home if it’s damaged or destroyed.
The table below outlines the average annual homeowners insurance premiums for different dwelling coverage amounts.
| Dwelling Coverage Amount | Average Annual Premium |
| $200,000 | $895 |
| $250,000 | $982 |
| $300,000 | $1,075 |
| $350,000 | $1,180 |
| $400,000 | $1,290 |
Find Home Insurance in Madison
Compare Home Insurance Rates To Other Cities In Wisconsin
The following table shows the average rates of home insurance across various cities in Wisconsin.
| City | Annual Premium |
| Green Bay | $1,040 |
| Milwaukee | $1,262 |
| Racine | $1,125 |
| Appleton | $1,060 |
| Kenosha | $1,157 |
Bundle Home With Auto Insurance
Bundling your homeowners insurance with your auto insurance is a popular way to lower premiums. Many insurance providers offer discounts when you combine multiple policies, as they see it as an opportunity to retain you as a customer across different types of coverage. The savings from bundling can vary, but it’s common to see discounts ranging from 15% to 20% on your home insurance premium.
This method can be especially useful for homeowners who already have an auto insurance policy. By consolidating both policies with the same insurer, you simplify your insurance management and may receive better overall customer service. In addition to lower premiums, bundling may also provide more flexible payment options and potentially higher coverage limits.
Before deciding to bundle, it’s important to compare the total cost of bundling with the cost of purchasing separate policies. While bundling may offer discounts, it’s still worth ensuring that each individual policy provides the coverage you need at a reasonable rate.
How To Get Homeowners Insurance In Wisconsin
With informative sites like Insuranceopedia, finding the best coverage for your unique needs is just a few clicks away. By providing quick online quotes from a variety of top-rated insurers, Insuranceopedia helps you to compare rates at a glance.
Just input your details and let us do the hard work, presenting you with a range of options tailored to your requirements. This way, you can confidently choose a policy that offers the highest value, balancing cost with comprehensive coverage.
Our Methodology
To find the cheapest home insurance rates in Madison, we analyzed findings from numerous home insurance review sites, some of which analyzed rates from public filings obtained by Quadrant Information Services. We’ve used an average of those rates for this review, but each company’s rates change frequently and will vary based on your situation. Also factored into the overall rating is my subjective opinion based on fifteen years of experience as a licensed insurance agent and over three decades of purchasing home insurance.
About Bob Phillips
