Best Life Insurance Companies in San Antonio, TX For May, 2024

Nationwide comes out top as the most recommended life insurance company in San Antonio.

min read
Updated: 19 March 2024
Written by
Bob Phillips
On this page Open

Ensuring that your loved ones are financially stable after you pass is something that we all would like, but knowing which life insurance policy to go for can, at times, feel somewhat overwhelming – especially when the market has so many options to choose from.

It’s for this very reason that we have put together a list of some of the best life insurance companies available in San Antonio, and after in-depth research concluded that Nationwide came out top as our most recommended, based on their fantastic service and their range of products available, as well as their fair premiums.

My experience as a career agent means that I have a great deal of knowledge in this field and have often encountered several of the companies discussed here. The target demographic differs depending on the company; however, they all deliver exceptional customer service and are all financially solid.

Best life insurance providers in San Antonio, TX 2024

Best life insurance, San Antonio, 2024

Comparing the best life insurance in San Antonio, TX

Below is a table designed to support you in your decision-making around life insurance providers in San Antonio. As part of our evaluation, we have outlined companies highly recommended by yours truly, with each highlighting varying key elements.

Overall Rating Best For A.M. Best Rating J.D. Power Rating (Best 1000) Online Experience Get A Quote
MassMutual
4.8

Best Overall Runner-Up

A

780

9.5

Instant Quote
Nationwide
4.9

Best Overall

A++

791

9.4

Instant Quote
Mutual of Omaha
4.8

Best for Seniors

A+

801

9.2

Instant Quote
Transamerica
4.7

Best for Young Adults

A

740

9.7

Instant Quote
Mass Mutual
4.8

Best for Cheapest Life Insurance

A++

780

9.6

Instant Quote
USAA
4.8

Best for Military Families

A+

NR

9.6

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Our Approach

We carried out a comprehensive evaluation of San Antonio’s life insurance providers, involving a range of different criteria. Factors considered include the range of products available, premium rates, online experience, and overall customer service, with additional insight from my time spent as a career agent.

72

Quotes Analyzed

20

Brands Reviewed

25+

Years Of Experiece

41

Research Hours

Best Life Insurance Companies In San Antonio


Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

With fantastic financial ratings, highly competitive premiums, and superb customer satisfaction levels, Nationwide is one of the best life insurance companies available on the market.

As one of the most renowned life insurance providers, Nationwide has a team consisting of the most highly skilled career agents, and a network of independent agents who have been specifically selected as representatives of the company. The aptly chosen blanket as their marketing symbol further proves the additional layer of security that Nationwide provides.

Both term and permanent life insurance policies are on offer at Nationwide, including the option for whole life, universal life, and variable universal life insurance. A plan requiring no medical check is also available with Nationwide.

Buying life insurance from Nationwide is incredibly straightforward. For those who prefer an in-person meeting, there are a number of local branches within San Antonio. And depending on your individual wants and needs, after a phone call with the team you will be referred to a Nationwide career agent who will be more than happy to help you out.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Among the more cost-friendly of providers
  • Fantastic network of highly skilled agents
  • Complete line of life insurance products available
Drawbacks
  • Term life applications are restricted to people aged 70 and below
  • Quotes for permanent products are unavailable online

Best Overall Runner-Up

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

Often considered as a close second in the list of the best life insurance companies in San Antonio is MassMutual. Although their head office is in Massachusetts, MassMutual has been a top provider of life insurance for the people of San Antonio for several years.

MassMutual’s team is made up of highly skilled professionals who have undergone extensive training during the course of their career. When it comes to determining the most appropriate type and face amount of life insurance for their clients, MassMutual’s approach consists of a detailed life insurance needs analysis.

They have a variety of different life insurance products available including whole life insurance, universal life insurance, and term life insurance. Also on offer with MassMutual is a variable universal life policy which combines mutual funds with a death benefit to increase cash value.

Compared to their competitors, MassMutual’s overheads are a little higher. This is primarily down to the Class A offices located across the country, not to mention the funds invested when training their workforce. Despite their increased overheads, they still offer extremely competitive rates on all of their products.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Claims can be filed online
  • Both term and permanent policy options on offer
  • In-person or online breakdown policies available to suit client’s preferences
Drawbacks
  • Permanent policies cannot be applied for online
  • If a customer purchases a term policy online, they cannot then switch to a permanent policy

Best for Young Adults

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

Transamerica’s pyramid building located in San Francisco is one thing that the company is most famous for. However, Transamerica is also highly represented in San Antonio, with a number of independent life insurance agents selling their policies. They are also outstanding in that they have extremely affordable term life insurance, as well as a term life product on offer for young adults.

In addition to their fantastic premiums, Transamerica provides a seamless online experience for its users – with a big focus on encouraging younger people to purchase life insurance. Quotes are also available through their site.

Customers preferring an in-person discussion can take advantage of their ‘Locate an Agent’ feature, which can be found on their website. This feature helps customers to find an agent nearest to them, who represents the company.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Term life insurance available to be purchased online
  • Face amounts for policies go up to $10 million
  • A medical exam is not required for qualifying applicants, for up to $2 million
Drawbacks
  • Final Expense Policy not guaranteed issue
  • Minimum term life insurance face amount is $25,000

Best for Families

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

A.M. Best awarded USAA with an A+ (Superior) rating, given that they are financially solid and have superb claims payment ability. USAA’s property and casualty products cater specifically to active military members, veterans, and their families. However, for people who have no connection to the military but are a U.S citizen/permanent resident, USAA’s life insurance is still available for purchase.

USAA’s compassionate and friendly ‘Survivor Relations’ team are there to support the loved ones of the deceased policy owner, helping them to settle claims for all accounts and policies. Additionally, USAA also offers a guaranteed issue life insurance product issued by Mutual of Omaha. A medical examination is not required for this product, which is also available in San Antonio.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Complete line of life insurance products
  • No medical exam required for certain term life policies
  • Products are available to non-military US citizens, and permanent residents
Drawbacks
  • Limited term life plans in comparison to its competitors
  • Essential Term available only to customers aged between 21 and 35

Best For Cheapest Life Insurance

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
8/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

For customers seeking more affordable premiums in San Antonio, MassMutual is our no.1 recommendation. They offer the most competitive rates for men and women, surpassing other established insurers including Prudential, Nationwide, State Farm, and Mutual of Omaha. MassMutual has a deep understanding of the profitability of the term life insurance marketplace for providers, and in doing so – have priced their products appropriately.

With policies on offer lasting 1, 10, 15, 25, or 30 years, MassMutual is a solid choice for people looking to purchase term life insurance – with coverage beginning at $100,000. Should a policy owner later decide that they want to switch to permanent coverage, then many term life policies can be converted, such as universal life or whole life.

On top of that, they have built a great reputation through their customer support as they received less complaints than originally anticipated, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Additionally, they ranked 9th place out of 22 for customer satisfaction in JD Power’s 2022 U.S ranking of insurance providers.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Lowest rates overall in San Antonio
  • Claims can be filed online
  • Online and in-person breakdown of all products available
Drawbacks
  • If a term policy is purchased online, it cannot then be switched to permanent
  • Online applications for permanent policies not available

Best for Seniors

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claims
9/10 Coverage level

Why We Like Them

I have personal experience with Mutual of Omaha, working as a licensed career agent for over 5 years. During this time, I witnessed their comprehensive understanding of the senior market. As part of their senior life product life, a guaranteed issue whole life product is included, and this is issued regardless of your health history. This essentially means that a customer will not be denied coverage, although their rates do tend to be a little higher due to the financial risks.

Avoiding paying the higher rates that come with a guaranteed issue policy is an option with their simplified issue product for seniors. The application process asks a few medical questions, but no medical exam is required. Rates for this simplified issue product are in fact lower, however, coverage is not necessarily guaranteed. An applicant can be rejected if there is a history of heart problems, or cancer.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Highly skilled agents selling senior life policies
  • A complete line of senior products including life insurance and Medicare Supplements
  • No medical exam required for senior applicants
Drawbacks
  • Limited term life plans in comparison to its competitors
  • Fewer face amounts for senior life products

Discovering the best life insurance provider for you

After undergoing an extensive analysis of the top insurance companies, we can confidently say that each provider mentioned has something to suit anyone’s needs. One thing to note is that some companies can benefit you more than others – it depends entirely on your own personal situation.

If you’re 65 and looking to purchase a whole life policy of $25,000 – Mutual of Omaha could be the choice best suited to you. If you’re 35 – Nationwide may be the better option.

MassMutual offers a better experience for people wanting to have an in-person discussion. When deciding on a provider, ask yourself the following five questions:

  1. Is the company financially strong?
  2. Does the company offer the type of policy I’m looking for?
  3. Do I want to discuss policies in-person, or do I prefer to search for policies online?
  4. Does the company offer competitive rates for my age?
  5. Does the company have positive online reviews overall?

Remember, your situation is unique to you. Any quotes, rates, products on offer can vary – so don’t worry if they look different to your family or neighbor’s.

Biggest life insurance providers in Texas

Many insurance providers operate in Texas. Listed below are companies that are the biggest, as measured by market share:

Company Market Share
Northwestern Mutual 7%
Lincoln Financial 6%
New York Life 6%
Transamerica 4%
MassMutual 4%
Pacific Life 4%
State Farm 4%

Average Cost of Life Insurance in San Antonio, TX

Average Cost of Life Insurance in San Antonio for Women

(Average age 30, average weight of 153, average coverage need of $680,000)

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $926,000 Coverage (Recommended)
Nationwide $11 $15
Mutual of Omaha $11 $16
MassMutual $9 $14
Transamerica $14 $23
State Farm $18 $32
AAA $16 $35
Progressive $17 $37

Average Cost of Life Insurance in San Antonio for Men

(Average age 30, average weight of 193, average coverage need of $680,000)

Company Rates for $250,000 Coverage Rates for $926,000 Coverage (Recommended)
MassMutual $12 $18
Nationwide $12 $17
Mutual of Omaha $11 $16
Transamerica $14 $26
State Farm $18 $34
AAA $17 $41
Progressive $22 $45

Average Cost of life insurance for young people in San Antonio

(Male, average age of 25, average weight of 167, average coverage need of $270,000)

Company Rates for $270,000 Coverage
Nationwide $20
State Farm $22
Progressive $21

Average Cost of life insurance for seniors in San Antonio

(Average age 60, average weight of 197, average coverage need of $82,000)

Company Rates for $82,000 Coverage
MassMutual $36
Mutual of Omaha $41
Nationwide $43
State Farm $50
Progressive $66

Important Texas life insurance laws

Insurance providers in Texas have state guidelines that they must follow by law. These are put in place to protect policyholders and outline how policies work.

Free look period

If a policyholder wishes to cancel their life insurance within 10 days of purchasing the policy, they are entitled to a full refund of their initial premium payment.

If a policyholder wishes to cancel after 10 days of receiving the policy, a full refund of their initial premium payment will be issued.

Guaranty Fund Protection

After a premium payment is made, coverage is instantly protected by the Texas Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association. If a provider fails, the association guarantees coverage of up to $300,000 in life insurance death benefits, including $100,000 in life insurance cash value.

Contestable period

Texas provides a contestability period of up to two years. During this period, insurers can reject claims if they discover that an applicant submitted false information.

Time allowed to settle a claim

Texan insurers must make payouts within two months of receiving evidence that a policyholder has deceased. Interest will also start to accrue on the day the insurer receives this proof.

Grace period for missed payments

A grace period of 31 days is given to policyholders in Texas, should they miss a payment. After this time, coverage may be canceled. This grace period is put in place to allow policyholders to catch up with any missed payments.

Information about San Antonio

San Antonio is the seventh most populous city in the United States, and the second most populous city in Texas. Famous for its rich Hispanic culture, and the historic role that it played in the Texan Independence, San Antonio is a fantastic city that attracts tourists from all corners of the globe, with its superb museums and delicious food.

San Antonio’s month-long celebration, Fiesta San Antonio, is an annual event that brings the city to a standstill. Highlights of the Fiesta include parades, live music, and mouth-watering local cuisine, as well as tasty Tex-Mex dishes. Famous architecture and landmarks found in San Antonio are The Alamo, San Fernando Cathedral, and the Japanese Tea Garden. Their most famous sports team are the San Antonio Spurs, winning five NBA Championships, six conference titles, and 22 division titles.

FAQs

How expensive is life insurance in Texas?

The cost of life insurance in Texas depends on a number of things including age, height, weight, smoking habits, and health history. Coverage of up to $270,000 is available for young adults, with a small monthly payment of $18 per month.

Do I need life insurance in San Antonio?

If you live in San Antonio and have family members who depend on you financially, then considering life insurance is vital. Policies can help your family to keep a roof over their heads, cover college expenses, and cover end-of-life costs.

How much life insurance do I need in San Antonio?

The amount of coverage needed depends on your family situation, as well as your financial circumstances. However, many insurance agents and providers recommend that a working individual obtains coverage of up to 7-10 times their annual salary. This ensures that loved ones will be supported financially should a passing happen unexpectedly. It will also act as a replacement for any lost income.

Go back to top