Nearly 1 in 3 Homeowners Who Filed an Insurance Claim Got Less Than Expected or Nothing at All

Home insurance claims- Insuranceopedia.com
Min read
Published:
Written by
Jastra Kranjec
On this page Open ⇅

Key Takeaways

  • Nearly three in four homeowners who received less than expected or nothing at all didn’t push back

  • Nearly 60% don’t know a claim can stay on their record even if it pays nothing

As the world’s largest insurance market, accounting for nearly 45% of global insurance premiums, the United States has a surprisingly high share of insured homeowners who are unsure what their policy covers, when it’s worth filing a claim, and what happens if they appeal their insurer’s decision. In other words, many of them are facing a repair bill without knowing how much help they can expect from their insurer.

According to Insuranceopedia’s Homeowner Claims Survey, nearly one in three homeowners who filed an insurance claim got less than expected or nothing at all.

Nearly Three in Four Homeowners Who Received Less Than Expected or Nothing at All Didn’t Push Back

Many homeowners only find out what their home insurance will pay once they have a repair bill. That’s when they may learn that some damage isn’t covered or that they’ll have to pay more out of pocket than they expected.

To better understand how confident they feel before filing a claim, Insuranceopedia surveyed 700 insured U.S. homeowners and found that only one in four (25%) were very confident they could tell whether their policy covered the damage and whether it was worth making a claim. Another 58% were somewhat confident, while 17%, or nearly one in five, were not very confident or not confident at all.

Among the 337 respondents who had filed a claim, 27% received less than expected on their most recent claim, while another 5% had their claim closed with no payment. Together, that’s almost one in three claimants (32%) who received less than expected or nothing.

While receiving less than expected might seem like a reason to ask the insurer to take another look, the survey also showed that most homeowners in this position didn’t take that next step. Among the respondents whose latest claim paid less than expected or closed with no payment, nearly three in four (72%) didn’t challenge the decision.

As for why, 30% of respondents who got less than expected or nothing at all said they didn’t know they could ask their insurer to take another look. Another 31% didn’t think it was worth it, while 8% thought it would be too complicated or take too much time.

Nearly 60% Don’t Know a Claim Can Stay on Their Record Even if It Pays Nothing

Another thing homeowners were unsure about was their deductible. Across all 700 respondents, only 33% knew the exact amount. Another 43% had a rough idea, while 24% didn’t know it at all. In other words, two in three respondents didn’t know exactly how much they would have to pay themselves when making a claim.

When asked whether they would file a claim for repairs costing only a little more than their deductible, 49% said no, 26% weren’t sure, and only 25% said they would file.

For those unsure what to do, understanding how much their insurer might pay is an important starting point, and one of the reasons Insuranceopedia created Claims Assistant.

“Homeowners shouldn’t have to file a claim just to find out whether their insurance will help,” said Max Coupland, CEO of Insuranceopedia. “We created Claims Assistant to help them understand what their policy covers, how much they would need to pay themselves and whether a claim is worth making. Sometimes that means telling them they’re better off not filing.”

The tool checks the damage against the homeowner’s coverage and if they decide to file, it also helps them prepare the paperwork and keep track of deadlines.

But before homeowners decide whether to file, there’s one more thing to keep in mind. A claim can still show up on their insurance record even if the insurer pays nothing. Nearly 60% of respondents didn’t know that.

Methodology

Insuranceopedia surveyed 700 U.S. homeowners with current homeowners insurance through Pollfish on October 9, 2026. Results are unweighted and self-reported. The reported margin of error at 95% confidence is ±3.7 percentage points overall. Smaller-group findings should be treated as directional.

About Jastra Kranjec

Jastra is a data-driven PR specialist with 20+ years of experience across journalism, public relations, and content strategy, specializing in research and report writing.

Read Full Bio