Best Condo Insurance In Wisconsin

Condo insurance typically runs about $530 per year in Wisconsin, and Nationwide is the state’s top-rated insurance provider.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $450 per year on their home insurance.

Compare Quotes
Offers from America's top insurance carriers
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Published:
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

The Garden State frequently experiences severe weather like thunderstorms and tornadoes, posing a risk to condos. While Wisconsin doesn’t mandate condo insurance, your lender may require it. This insurance provides financial security by covering losses due to damage or theft.

Additionally, some HOA agreements might necessitate dwelling coverage. To be fully protected, select a policy that includes multiple risk types. If you’re new to this, use this guide to find the best condo insurance in Wisconsin.

Best Condo Insurance Companies In Wisconsin, 2025

Best Condo Insurance, Wisconsin, 2025

Compare The Best Condo Insurance Policies In Wisconsin

Best For Overall Rating A.M Best Rating J.D Power Rating Get A Quote
Nationwide

Overall

4.9

A+

816

Instant Quote
Travelers

Discounts

4.6

A

794

Instant Quote
Amica

Runner-Up

4.8

A+

849

Instant Quote
Chubb

High-Value Condos

4.7

A++

809

Instant Quote
Scroll to see comparisons

Best Condo Insurance Companies In Wisconsin 2025


Best For High-Value Condos

Overall Rating
4.7

Key Statistics

7/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

For high-end condo owners in Wisconsin, Chubb is a top provider known for its outstanding service and tailored coverage. The Masterpiece policy includes extended replacement cost coverage, ensuring rebuild costs are covered even if they surpass the insured value. Chubb’s additional options, such as identity fraud and cyber protection, cater to the needs of affluent individuals. Their high coverage limits guarantee premium protection for luxury properties.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Offers broader insurance coverage
  • Exceptional client handling
  • Only a handful of complaints were made.
Drawbacks
  • Designed for deluxe condominiums
  • Exceeds the standard industry pricing.
  • Missing BBB accreditation.

Best Runner-Up

Overall Rating
4.8

Key Statistics

8/10 Affordability
9/10 Customer Reviews
9/10 Claim Payouts
10/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Amica claims the second spot by offering Wisconsin condo owners diverse coverage options. The Platinum Choice policy provides superior coverage limits and extra protections beyond standard offerings. Affordable rates, often lower than Allstate’s, make Amica an attractive option. Customers who bundle their condo and auto insurance can save up to 20%. The company also excels in customer service and satisfaction, further enhancing its reputation.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Diversity in coverage choices
  • Low incidence of customer complaints
  • Insurer with a strong financial base.
Drawbacks
  • Rates that are higher than the standard.
  • During 2017, AM Best's rating was reduced.
  • States differ in offering condo insurance dividend options.

Best Overall

Overall Rating
4.9

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
10/10 Customer Reviews
10/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Nationwide ranks first for offering comprehensive insurance tailored to individual needs. Their policies cover personal items like furniture and clothing and additional living expenses (ALE) for temporary housing if your condo is damaged. Policyholders can also add endorsements to enhance their coverage. Known for fair claims handling and excellent customer service, Nationwide delivers an exceptional experience from start to finish.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Competitive cost
  • A vast variety of coverage selections
  • High-quality customer care
Drawbacks
  • Intended for high-value condominiums.
  • Discounts with a restricted availability.
  • Potential for miscellaneous expenses

Best For Discounts

Overall Rating
4.6

Key Statistics

9/10 Affordability
8/10 Customer Reviews
8/10 Claim Payouts
9/10 Coverage Level

Why We Like Them

Wisconsin condo owners can benefit from Travelers Insurance’s wide range of discounts and affordable coverage options. Their multi-policy discount provides up to 15% savings when bundling condo and auto insurance, offering both cost efficiency and convenience. Travelers also rewards installing safety features like smart home devices with a protective device discount. Even with these comprehensive offerings, Travelers maintains some of the lowest rates available.

Benefits & Drawbacks

Benefits
  • Affordable charges
  • Choice to bundle several types of insurance coverage
  • Excellent fiscal soundness evaluation
Drawbacks
  • Limited span
  • There could exist a lineup of prohibited dog types.

How Much Is Condo Insurance In Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin, condo insurance typically runs about $530 per year. State Farm offers the lowest rates, averaging $275 annually. See the table for annual premium comparisons among ten top condo insurance providers.

Insurance Company Average Annual Rate
State Farm $275
American Family $500
Auto-Owners $378
Nationwide $332
Allstate $350

Average Cost Of Condo Insurance In Wisconsin – By City

Displayed in the table are the average condo insurance premiums in major Wisconsin cities.

City Average Annual Rate
Milwaukee $578
Oshkosh $517
Waukesha $524
Appleton $512
Eau Claire $524

Condo Insurance Rates In Wisconsin – By Building Property Limits

Condo insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all—it depends on the cost to rebuild your condominium. Below is a comparison table of average monthly premiums for different coverage limits.

Building Property Limit Average Annual Rate
$40,000 $486
$60,000 $529
$80,000 $567
$100,000 $610

Avoid concentrating solely on finding the cheapest insurance rates; look for a policy that balances cost, coverage, financial stability, and quality customer service.

How To Get An Online Condo Insurance Quote In Wisconsin

To find quality condo insurance in Wisconsin, comparing quotes from multiple insurers is the best approach. Insuranceopedia is a great site to begin your search. To get an accurate quote, you’ll need to provide the following:

  • Name
  • Condo address
  • Year of construction
  • Exterior wall construction
  • Square footage of the condo
  • Estimated rebuilding cost
  • Value of personal property
  • Number of occupants
  • Your claims history
  • Installed safety features

Factors That Impact The Cost Of Your Condo Insurance Policy

Condo insurance costs in Wisconsin depend on factors like:

  • Rebuild Value: Higher replacement costs equal higher premiums.
  • Location Hazards: High-risk areas, like those prone to storms or crime, raise rates.
  • Property Age: Older systems increase costs, while modern materials can lower them.
  • Claims History: A clean record can earn discounts, while frequent claims may raise premiums.

Most Expensive ZIP Codes For Condo Insurance In Wisconsin

Wisconsin’s 54020 ZIP code sees the highest condo insurance rates, averaging $1,898 each year.

ZIP Code Average Yearly Premium
54723 $1,872
54023 $1,871
54028 $1,896
54020 $1,898

Cheapest ZIP Codes For Condo Insurance In Wisconsin

The annual average for condo insurance in ZIP code 53081 is $1,488, making it the least expensive option.

ZIP Code Average Yearly Premium
53085 $1,508
54246 $1,507
53081 $1,488
54234 $1,492

How Much Condo Insurance Do I Need In Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin, the level of condo insurance required depends on several factors, including your condo’s layout, the value of your personal possessions, and the coverage provided by your condo association’s master insurance policy. It’s worth considering adding loss assessment coverage to your policy to safeguard against expenses related to damages or losses in shared condo spaces.

How To Save Money On Wisconsin Condo Insurance

If you’re aiming for affordable condo insurance in Wisconsin, one simple option is to increase your deductible. While this typically reduces your premiums, keep in mind that you’ll have to pay more out-of-pocket if you file a claim. Another strategy is to weatherproof and secure your condo. Installing storm shutters or security systems can reduce the risk of damage or theft, potentially lowering your insurance costs.

How Much Condo Insurance Is Legally Required In Wisconsin?

Wisconsin doesn’t mandate condo insurance, though many lenders and condo associations do. Most policies include liability coverage with limits starting at $100,000 and reaching up to $500,000.

How To Find The Best Condo Insurance Company For You

A tailored condo insurance policy safeguards your property and personal items while providing financial protection. Here’s how to find the right one:

Determine how much coverage you need.

1

Search for insurers online and pick three options.

2

Request quotes from each.

3

Compare them on coverage, cost, and reputation.

4

Buy a policy that matches your needs.

5

Compare Condo Insurance Rates To Other States

State Average Annual Premium
Alabama $607
Alaska $418
Arizona $440
Arkansas $578
California $605
Colorado $479
Connecticut $403
Delaware $498
Florida $1,069
Georgia $553
Hawaii $368
Idaho $483
Illinois $407
Indiana $384
Iowa $299
Kansas $397
Kentucky $391
Louisiana $786
Maine $408
Maryland $331
Massachusetts $461
Michigan $360
Minnesota $351
Mississippi $634
Missouri $388
Montana $521
Nebraska $391
Nevada $477
New Hampshire $381
New Jersey $429
New Mexico $433
New York $475
North Carolina $519
North Dakota $287
Ohio $315
Oklahoma $655
Oregon $400
Pennsylvania $390
Rhode Island $587
South Carolina $530
South Dakota $328
Tennessee $492
Texas $873
Utah $301
Vermont $375
Virginia $372
Washington $400
West Virginia $331

Our Methodology

In my search for the top condo insurance companies in Wisconsin, I evaluated customer satisfaction and financial strength ratings provided by reputable agencies like J.D. Power and AM Best. Additionally, I considered consumer feedback and drew on my firsthand experience as a licensed property and casualty agent specializing in condo insurance in the state.

127

Quotes Analyzed

38

Brands Reviewed

15+

Years Of Experience

30+

Research Hours

FAQs

What Does Condo Insurance Cover In Wisconsin?

Known as an HO-6 policy, condo insurance covers the interior of your condominium and its contents against unexpected damage or loss. This includes elements like walls, floors, fixtures, and cabinets, as well as personal belongings. Additionally, condo insurance provides liability coverage and usually includes $1,000 for loss assessment coverage to address damages affecting communal areas in the condominium complex. You have the option to enhance coverage limits with a policy endorsement.

How does condo insurance work?

Condo insurance offers financial peace of mind to condo owners by protecting their condos and personal belongings from various risks with a diverse range of coverage options and supplementary policy features.

About Bob Phillips

Having spent over fifteen years helping people plan their lives financially, Bob mastered many different financial products to help people achieve their financial goals, including life insurance, disability insurance, mutual funds, and stocks and bonds.
Read Full Bio
Go back to top