Toyota Sienna Car Insurance Cost

Getting insurance for a Toyota Sienna typically comes with an annual cost of approximately $723 from New York Central Mutual Fire. However, the actual expenses can vary based on factors like your age, the year of your car model, and other relevant factors. Refer to the quote tables provided below to estimate the potential cost tailored to your situation.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 03 October 2024
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

If you’re thinking about buying a Toyota Sienna, you’ll need to factor in the cost of insurance. Insurance is a significant aspect of owning a car, so it’s important to understand it before making a purchase.

Selecting the right car insurance is crucial to avoid unexpected and potentially high expenses later on. It’s essential to have adequate coverage in case of an accident to avoid significant out-of-pocket costs. Additionally, being found at fault in an accident could result in higher premiums.

With more than ten years of experience analyzing car insurance rates, I’ve observed how much these costs can vary. Factors like your age, driving record, and location can have a significant impact on your insurance premiums.

How Much Does Toyota Sienna Car Insurance Cost?

Typically, New York Central Mutual Fire provides the most competitive price, charging about $723 annually for full coverage insurance on a 2024 Toyota Sienna.

Although the rate offered by New York Central Mutual Fire serves as a good reference point, it’s essential to realize that car insurance costs can vary significantly due to various factors. These factors include your location, driving history, the model year of your car, and the specific coverage options you choose. Maintaining a clean driving record typically results in lower premiums, while a history of accidents or traffic violations can raise your costs.

Furthermore, residing in an urban area with heavy traffic often translates to higher insurance rates compared to rural areas with less traffic. The type of coverage you select also plays a role in determining your premium – comprehensive coverage, which includes both comprehensive and collision coverage, tends to be more expensive than basic liability coverage.

Insuranceopedia is available to assist you in shopping around and comparing quotes from different insurance companies to ensure you secure the best deal possible.

2024 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Utica National Ins Group $1,014
GMAC Insurance Group $1,520
Mercury $1,458
North Carolina Farm Bureau $1,342
New York Central Mutual Fire $723
Erie $1,014
SECURA Insurance $973
Esurance $1,537
USAA $1,560
Titan $1,370

2023 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
PEMCO $761
New Jersey Manufacturers $1,452
Allied $1,258
Dairyland $1,091
Safeco $29
Capital Insurance Group $819
Mercury Insurance $614
Oregon Mutual $1,304
Mercury Insurance Company $1,395
GMAC Insurance Group $1,240

2022 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
PEMCO $715
Mercury Insurance Company $1,204
Tennessee Farmers $1,166
Capital Insurance Group $1,126
Victoria $390
Pekin Insurance $876
Safeco $630
SECURA Insurance $1,204
Virginia Farm Bureau $1,209
AssuranceAmerica $1,129

2021 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Victoria $415
Capital Insurance Group $1,028
PEMCO $866
Dairyland Broadform $636
Safeco $141
American National P $537
Kemper Auto | Infinity $389
Virginia Farm Bureau $926
NatGen PPA $1,030
NatGen Custom 360 $821

2020 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
American National P $604
Virginia Farm Bureau $1,012
PEMCO $940
Texas Farm Bureau Group $904
Concord Group $495
Countryway Insurance $910
Safeco $482
MMG Insurance Company $980
Clearcover $1,004
Capital Insurance Group $918

2019 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
American National P $666
PEMCO $954
Buckeye Insurance Group $890
Western Reserve $854
Safeco $78
Pekin Insurance $686
Mercury Insurance $500
SECURA Insurance $914
Rockford Mutual Insurance $911
Indiana Farmers Mutual Ins $868

2018 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Pekin Insurance $603
Atlantic States Insurance $940
United Farm Bureau of IN Group $867
Tennessee Farmers $789
American National P $470
Buckeye Insurance Group $752
Dairyland $471
Indiana Farmers Mutual Ins $894
PEMCO $910
Safeco $839

2017 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
PEMCO $713
Plymouth Rock Assurance $856
SafeAuto $826
Pekin Insurance $737
American National P $646
Safeco $740
Mercury Insurance $700
Texas Farm Bureau Group $817
Mercury Insurance Company $868
Buckeye Insurance Group $821

2016 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Texas Farm Bureau Group $608
Clearcover $1,042
North Carolina Farm Bureau $821
SECURA Insurance $729
Safeco $394
Mercury Insurance $582
American National P $451
PEMCO $858
First Chicago Insurance $994
Buckeye Insurance Group $810

2015 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Kemper Personal Insurance $444
NatGen Advantage $846
Kentucky Farm Bureau $729
American National P $606
Mercury Insurance $247
American National P&C $523
Safeco $382
Cameron Mutual Group $770
PEMCO $776
Infinity Special $705

2014 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
PEMCO $485
Kentucky Farm Bureau $720
Safeco $602
Concord Group $558
Buckeye Insurance Group $442
NatGen Value $496
American National P $456
Pekin Insurance $663
Ohio Mutual Ins Group $708
Western Reserve $541

2013 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Union Mutual Fire Group $619
Utica National Ins Group $745
Patriot Group $677
PEMCO $662
American National P $410
Concord Group $586
National General Value $458
Acuity $755
Mercury Insurance Company $736
MMG Insurance Company $657

2012 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
Safeco $216
Patriot Group $604
MMG Insurance Company $499
AssuranceAmerica Elite $320
Kemper Personal Insurance $22
Mercury Insurance $319
AssuranceAmerica Economy $233
NatGen PPA $459
Concord Group $568
PEMCO $448

2011 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
NatGen Custom 360 $250
Kentucky Farm Bureau $605
Kemper Auto $495
American National P $443
Safeco $76
Dairyland Broadform $294
Kemper Personal Insurance $245
Mercury Insurance $591
Dairyland FR Bond $571
PEMCO $526

2010 Toyota Sienna Insurance Rates

Insurance Provider Average Annual Cost
American National P $389
Indiana Farmers Mutual Ins $719
PEMCO $687
Texas Farm Bureau Group $609
Safeco $108
Buckeye Insurance Group $590
Mercury Insurance $271
SECURA Insurance $716
Southern Farm Bureau $717
Utica National Ins Group $665

Find Affordable Volkswagen Golf R Car Insurance

Free. Secure. No Spam.

Cost of Toyota Sienna Car Insurance By Age

Drive Age Good Driver Recent Accident Poor Credit
17 $7,601 $11,230 $13,132
18 $7,102 $10,486 $12,230
19 $6,292 $9,282 $10,808
20 $5,471 $8,027 $9,425
21 $4,578 $6,808 $7,884
22 $4,516 $6,592 $7,686
23 $3,950 $5,737 $6,772
24 $3,769 $5,500 $6,418
25 $3,216 $4,733 $5,521
30 $2,534 $3,662 $4,304
35 $2,369 $3,447 $4,049
40 $2,272 $3,321 $3,890
45 $2,222 $3,225 $3,747
55 $1,999 $2,991 $3,432
65 $2,079 $3,109 $3,611
75 $2,629 $3,890 $4,543

Toyota Sienna Car Insurance Rates By State

State Good Driver Recent Accident Poor Credit
Alabama $2,375 $3,463 $4,413
Alaska $1,955 $2,737 $2,678
Arizona $2,240 $3,226 $4,764
Arkansas $2,483 $3,853 $4,243
California $2,774 $4,783 $2,738
Colorado $2,581 $3,588 $4,504
Connecticut $3,290 $5,043 $6,411
Delaware $2,711 $3,599 $4,587
Florida $3,237 $4,410 $5,791
Hawaii $1,024 $1,445 $1,039
Idaho $1,850 $2,412 $2,936
Illinois $1,910 $2,886 $3,261
Indiana $1,929 $3,008 $3,331
Iowa $1,543 $2,154 $2,491
Kansas $2,043 $2,984 $3,527
Kentucky $2,996 $4,384 $5,170
Louisiana $3,820 $5,758 $6,246
Maine $1,440 $1,989 $2,934
Maryland $2,325 $3,399 $3,806
Massachusetts $1,888 $3,283 $1,848
Michigan $4,536 $6,887 $10,829
Minnesota $1,908 $2,477 $3,507
Mississippi $2,249 $3,192 $3,220
Missouri $2,137 $3,042 $3,975
Montana $2,130 $2,990 $3,495
Nebraska $1,828 $2,694 $2,904
Nevada $3,017 $4,455 $4,726
New Hampshire $2,102 $3,289 $4,146
New Jersey $2,290 $3,565 $4,695
New Mexico $2,351 $3,486 $3,619
New York $2,175 $2,739 $4,584
North Carolina $1,327 $2,293 $1,623
North Dakota $1,841 $2,782 $3,305
Ohio $1,637 $2,559 $2,564
Oklahoma $2,657 $3,761 $4,250
Oregon $2,402 $3,250 $3,844
Pennsylvania $2,000 $2,954 $3,456
Rhode Island $3,375 $4,937 $5,528
South Carolina $2,301 $3,171 $4,372
South Dakota $2,032 $2,956 $3,384
Tennessee $2,418 $3,537 $4,709
Texas $2,392 $3,540 $4,363
Utah $2,041 $2,888 $3,946
Vermont $1,603 $2,421 $2,552
Virginia $1,524 $2,309 $2,267
Washington $1,985 $2,696 $3,174
West Virginia $1,976 $2,869 $3,580
Wisconsin $1,988 $3,130 $3,528
Wyoming $1,868 $2,601 $2,773
Georgia $2,639 $3,890 $3,946

Our Methodology

To ensure accurate and trustworthy insurance company ratings, I employed a detailed methodology. I assess numerous insurers, utilizing insights from reputable review sites and critical metrics from industry authorities such as A.M. Best and J.D. Power. With my 15 years of experience as an insurance agent, I enhance our analysis with firsthand knowledge, ensuring our ratings are reliable guides for your insurance decision-making process.

105

Quotes Analyzed

58

Brands Reviewed

40+

Research Hours

15+

Years Of Experience

Go back to top