Cheapest Car Insurance In Lehi, UT 2025

If you’re in Lehi, Farmers Union Insurance is the most budget-friendly option for minimum coverage, costing an average of $37 per month.

We’ve saved shoppers an average of $600 per year on their car insurance.

Explore offers from 100's of our trusted partners
Free. Secure. No Spam.
min read -
Updated: 22 January 2025
Written by Bob Phillips
On this page Open

If you’re on the hunt for low-cost car insurance in Lehi, UT, you’ll notice a lot of variation in pricing.

Farmers Union Insurance leads the pack for cheap liability-only coverage. For full coverage, Nationwide is the best choice, and Progressive caters to young drivers with the most competitive rates.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies In Lehi, UT 2025

National Farmers Union P&C
Cheapest for minimum coverage - Farmers Union Insurance
nationwide-icon-logo
Cheapest for seniors - Nationwide
Auto Owners Logo
Cheapest for teenagers - Auto-Owners
National Farmers Union P&C
Cheapest for drivers with prior incidents - Farmers Union Insurance
National Farmers Union P&C
Cheapest For Good Drivers - Farmers Union Insurance
Cheapest Car Insurance, Lehi, 2025

Cheapest Liability-only Car Insurance In Lehi: Farmers Union Insurance

Lehi drivers can find the cheapest minimum coverage car insurance through Farmers Union Insurance, which costs $37 a month on average.

Compare the rates of various insurance providers using the table below.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Farmers Union Insurance $37 $444
Auto-Owners $45 $540
Progressive $44 $528
Nationwide $39 $468
American Family $54 $648

Cheapest Full Coverage Insurance Rates In Lehi: Nationwide

Nationwide delivers the lowest rates for full coverage car insurance in Lehi, with an average cost of $68 per month.

A comparison of affordable auto insurance quotes in Lehi is provided in the table below.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Nationwide $68 $816
Progressive $90 $1080
American Family $81 $972
Auto-Owners $79 $948
Farmers Union Insurance $74 $888

Cheapest Rates In Lehi For Teenagers: Auto-owners

With an average monthly premium of $142, Auto-owners provides the most affordable coverage for teenage drivers in Lehi.

The following table highlights the companies with the lowest insurance premiums for teenagers.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Auto-owners $142 $1,704
American Family $489 $5,868
State Farm $387 $4,644
Allstate $448 $5,376
GEICO $330 $3,960

Cheapest Car Insurance Rates For Seniors: Nationwide

At $39 per month on average, Nationwide delivers the lowest car insurance rates for seniors in Lehi.

The following table provides a comparison of average auto insurance rates for seniors from affordable providers.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Nationwide $39 $468
GEICO $52 $624
Auto-Owners $48 $576
Progressive $44 $528
Farmers Union Insurance $40 $480

Cheapest Auto Insurance For Young Adults in Lehi: Progressive

At $49 per month, Progressive delivers the most budget-friendly quotes for young adults in Lehi.

The following table provides a comparison of the lowest auto insurance rates available in Lehi for young adults.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Progressive $49 $588
Farmers Union $53 $636
American Family $64 $768
GEICO $51 $612
Auto-Owners $60 $720

Cheapest Car Insurance In Lehi For Good Drivers: Farmers Union Insurance

For good drivers in Lehi, Farmers Union Insurance offers the most budget-friendly car insurance, averaging $37 a month.

Use the table below to find average insurance quotes from the most affordable companies for good drivers.

Provider Average Monthly Cost AverageAnnual Cost
Farmers Union Insurance $37 $444
Auto-Owners $45 $540
Progressive $44 $528
Nationwide $39 $468
American Family $54 $648

Find affordable Lehi rates

Free. Secure. No Spam.

Cheapest For Drivers With After At-Fault Accident: American Family

Drivers with an at-fault accident can find the most cost-effective car insurance with American Family, averaging $55 monthly.

These are the car insurance companies with the lowest premiums for drivers who’ve had an at-fault accident.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
American Family $55 $660
Nationwide $66 $792
GEICO $76 $912
Progressive $64 $768
Auto-Owners $73 $876

Cheapest Rates In Lehi For Drivers After A DUI: Progressive

With an average rate of $62 per month, Progressive offers the most budget-friendly car insurance for drivers after a DUI in Lehi.

The following table presents the best rates for Lehi drivers with a DUI on their record.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Progressive $62 $744
Farmers Union Insurance $70 $840
Kemper $81 $972
American Family $65 $780
Nationwide $82 $984

Cheapest Car Insurance In Lehi After A Speeding Ticket: Farmers Union Insurance

Drivers in Lehi with a speeding ticket can find affordable coverage from Farmers Union Insurance, with an average rate of $47 per month.

Check the table below for average rates for drivers with speeding tickets on their record.

Provider Average Monthly Cost Average Annual Cost
Farmers Union Insurance $47 $564
American Family $64 $768
GEICO $56 $672
Nationwide $45 $540
Auto-owners $61 $732

Best Car Insurance Companies In Lehi

For the best value in Lehi, Farmers Union Insurance offers insurance for $37 a month. Nationwide at $39 and Progressive at $44 per month are also affordable alternatives.

The table below ranks the top 10 car insurance companies in Lehi, UT, by their average monthly cost.

Company Monthly Premium
Farmers Union Insurance $37
Auto-Owners $45
Progressive $44
Nationwide $39
American Family $54
State Farm $120
Farm Bureau $73
Allstate $127
Farmers $168

Average Auto Insurance Rates In Lehi – By Age

Age is a major factor in how car insurance premiums are calculated. Young drivers face higher rates because they have less experience and a greater chance of accidents. Teenagers generally pay approximately $4,095 annually for car insurance.

For most drivers, rates begin to lower once they reach 25, provided they don’t have any driving violations on their record.

Drivers in their 50s and early 60s often benefit from the most competitive car insurance rates, as insurers view them as safer, more experienced drivers.

Age Average Yearly Rate
Teenagers $4,095
20s $1,871
30s $1,315
40s $1,541
50s $1,535
60s $1,069
70s $1,259

How Much Is Car Insurance In Other Cities in Utah?

Insurance rates are impacted by your city’s risk factors, such as accident rates, vehicle theft, and vandalism, which are typically higher in urban areas, resulting in higher premiums.

Drivers in Orem usually pay around $220 per month for car insurance, while those in cedar City pay an average of $178 each month.

City Average Monthly Rate
Orem $220
Layton $198
Park City $197
Sandy $214
Clearfield $206
Ogden $208
Hildale $184
Cedar City $178
Logan $186
Bountiful $201

Average Rates In Lehi – By Vehicle

The type of vehicle you drive—whether it’s a newer model, luxury car, or a specific make—affects your car insurance rates. Generally, newer cars, especially luxury models, have higher premiums due to higher replacement and repair costs.

The following table shows the average insurance rates for various vehicles in Lehi.

Vehicle Average Monthly Rate
Honda CRV $87
Dodge Charger $304
Kia Optima $250
Jeep Compass $142

Average Cost Of Auto Insurance In Lehi – By Zip Code

Since zip codes help insurers assess crime rates in specific areas, car insurance rates can differ depending on your zip code.

The following table lists the average car insurance rates for different zip codes in Lehi.

Zip Code Average Monthly Rate
84043 $151
84158 $82

Find affordable Lehi rates

Free. Secure. No Spam.

Our Methodology

After evaluating factors like customer service, product availability, pricing, and feedback from different online review platforms, I’ve developed a detailed overview of the car insurance landscape in Lehi, UT.

107

Quotes Analyzed

31

Brands Reviewed

15+

Years Of Experience

30+

Research Hours

FAQs

Who has the lowest car insurance rates in Lehi?

The most affordable car insurance rates in Lehi come from Farmers Union Insurance for the minimum coverage, and Nationwide for full coverage, including comprehensive and collision.

What is the average cost of car insurance in Lehi?

The average monthly cost for car insurance in Lehi is around $150, though your premium will depend on variables like your zip code, car year, model, and driving record.

Go back to top